Baby Wants To Be Held All The Time: Reasons And Ways To Stop It

Baby Wants To Be Held All The Time Reasons And Ways To Stop It

Image: Shutterstock

IN THIS ARTICLE

Babies love being held, especially when they are young since the world is a unique and new place for them. There is nothing wrong with holding your baby during their early years since it can help keep them warm and comfortable. Holding the baby in your arms or a carrier is also perhaps the only way to move them around until they can learn to sit correctly in a stroller.

While it is okay if the baby wants to be held all the time during infancy, it may become a concern and inconvenience if they demand being held during late infancy and toddlerhood. So when should you be concerned about your baby’s demands to be held?

Read on as in this post we tell you why babies want to be held all the time, its advantages, and when is the time to stop the habit.

Why Do Babies Want To Be Held All The Time?

There could be several reasons why a baby would like to be held depending on their age, health status, and personality. Below are some of the common reasons why babies may like to be held by parents all the time.

1. Comfort and security

A newborn is suddenly thrown into a noisy world from the calm and warm womb. Therefore, they instinctively desire touch by being held by parents, especially their mother. Babies who are just born can calm down and cry less when held close by the mother (1).

The comfort and security provided when being held resemble the womb’s environment. It is also believed that babies may calm down on hearing the mother’s heartbeat since they would be familiar with it (2). Babies may also recognize the scent of their mother, calming them down easily.

2. Illness and hunger

A baby who is unwell is likely to demand being held frequently. In such cases, you are likely to notice other signs of illness, such as fever and loss of appetite. Holding the baby close may help ease the discomfort caused by the illness.

Some babies may even demand to be held for frequent breastfeeding when hungry. It may likely be the case when they are experiencing growth spurts. A baby may also demand to be held and breastfed when thirsty. In such scenarios, look for other hunger indicators or hunger cues, such as placing thumbs in the mouth or moving their lips.

3. Separation anxiety and tantrums

Separation anxiety occurs when babies assume that when parents go out of sight, they leave forever. This feeling peaks between the ages of 10 and 18 months, and is usually gone by the age of three years (3). Babies who experience separation anxiety may demand being held when they see the parent and may not allow the parent to leave.

Toddlers may demand being held when they have a tantrum episode. For instance, if they are upset about a sibling taking their toy, they may demand being held and comforted by the parent. Some toddlers may only throw tantrums at a specific time, such as tantrums before bedtime. Toddlers may experience a sense of reward from parents’ attention during such situations (4).

What Are The Advantages Of Holding Your Baby?

Holding a baby, especially newborns, could provide the following benefits to the parent and the little one (1) (5) (6).

  1. Cuddling and skin-to-skin contact with a parent could help a newborn regulate their body temperature, heartbeat, and breathing.
  2. It can calm down an anxious and cranky baby, reducing any emotional distress.
  3. Some babies may sleep better when held before bedtime.
  4. Unwell babies may show improvement in minor symptoms, such as colic, due to an illness.
  5. It may help make chronic pain, such as teething pain, tolerable for a baby.
  6. It could help establish a healthy parent-baby bond where the baby promptly reaches out to a parent when experiencing discomfort.
  7. Research indicates that being held and cuddled could have therapeutic value since it may stimulate brain and body development in some babies.
  8. Mothers may notice they establish breastfeeding better when they hold their newborn often.
  9. Cuddling with the baby could help the mother relax, and it may improve her postpartum recovery.
  10. Holding the baby could be a great way for fathers, siblings, and other family members to bond with the baby.

Will My Baby Become Clingy? 

Experts believe that holding your baby often, especially when they need comfort and reassurance, is unlikely to make them clingy (7). Most babies cry and want to be held because they have a certain need, which can only be fulfilled by parents. In most cases, the baby will stop demanding to be held once the need is fulfilled. You are usually unlikely to spoil the baby by holding them all the time. However, the age of the baby could also play a role in the matter. 

When To Be Concerned? 

There could be certain scenarios when holding the baby all the time may not be appropriate. You may consult a doctor about your baby’s desire to be held all the time in the following scenarios (8).

  • The toddler is older than three years. Toddlers of this age usually learn of several ways to self-soothe and may communicate their anxiety rather than demand being held.
  • The baby continues to cry despite being held.
  • The demands to be held all the time usually arise at a specific time or during certain activities, such as at night or while playing with other children.
  • Comforting the baby or providing them alternative ways to soothe has no effect.
  • You sense that the baby’s anxiety and subsequent demand to be held interferes with their sleep or eat.
  • The baby has signs of infection or illness, such as fever, vomiting, or loss of appetite.

The doctor will assess the baby and determine the possible cause for frequent demands to be held all the time. It does not always mean that the child has a problem, and it could only be a personality attribute. There are several ways you may control the behavior right at home.

How To Stop Your Baby From Being Held All The Time?

Below are some ways to regulate your baby’s demands for being held.

1. Identify the need

It is best to hold the baby on demand up to the age of 12 months old. Babies up to this age are still developing emotionally and may require parent’s attention often. However, you may also try identifying the possible need of the baby. For instance, babies may understand and experiment with cause and effect from the age of six months. It may make them demand being held often only to gain extra attention from parents.

If they seem happy and cheerful, they are most likely need your attention. In such scenarios, you may avoid lifting them immediately if you are held up with other work. Gradually, the child will understand that they will only be held when they have an urgent need.

2. Give baby a chance to self-soothe

Research suggests that it is okay for the baby to cry for some time to figure out ways to self-soothe (9). There are several methods where you allow the baby to cry it out. If your baby is healthy and well-fed yet demands to be held, you may not address the demand immediately and rather let the baby self-soothe. Keep the baby within your line of sight, or you may stand in front of the baby but do not hold them.

3. Distract the baby 

Babies who want to be held all the time for non-essential reasons may be soothed easily with a distraction. You may show a toy to the baby or even provide them with a pacifier, which works great at keeping the baby calm (10). Swaddling the baby is another way to keep the baby calm, especially during bedtime and naps.

4. Manage separation anxiety

Figure out ways to manage separation anxiety. A good way to do it is by maintaining a regular routine where the toddler knows you are likely to be away for a fixed interval each day. Plan ways to keep the toddler engaged during this period by taking the help of a family member or letting the toddler stay at daycare.

You may also let the toddler have a comfort toy that they only receive when they are alone. It could reinforce confidence and make the child feel secure until you return.

5. Check if it is a tantrum

Older toddlers may want to be held all the time due to a tantrum. There are several ways to manage tantrums. A few examples are time-outs for 20 minutes, setting fixed rules, and ignoring the demand politely (11). You may also offer choices to the toddler if they seem vexed with an option.

Holding your baby all the time can be tiring for parents, especially for new mothers. However, this phase is transient, and the baby will learn ways to self-soothe than demand being held. You may explore various other ways to keep the baby or toddler engaged and reduce the probability of them turning to you for being held all the time.

References:

MomJunction's health articles are written after analyzing various scientific reports and assertions from expert authors and institutions. Our references (citations) consist of resources established by authorities in their respective fields. You can learn more about the authenticity of the information we present in our editorial policy.
1. The benefits of touch for babies, parents; Stanford Medicine
2. 6 Amazing Reasons Your Newborn Wants to be Held; Bay Area Breastfeeding and Education
3. Separation Anxiety; Stanford Children’s Health
4. How to Use Ignoring; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
5. Robert Giesler, Cuddling Does Kids (and Parents) Good; Children’s Hospital Los Angeles
6. Cuddling is good for babies — and you, too; University of California
7. Can you spoil a baby, or is that a myth?; Sanford Health
8. Early Warning Signs of Autism Spectrum Disorder; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
9. Claire McCarthy, New study says that it’s okay to let babies cry at night; Harvard Medical School
10. How to Calm a Fussy Baby: Tips for Parents & Caregivers; American Academy of Pediatrics
11. Temper tantrums; U.S. National Library of Medicine