15 Best Butter Dishes To Keep Butter Fresh For Long In 2024

A butter dish is a shallow container with a lid. It is used to store butter and keep it fresh for lengthy periods. The best butter dishes let you store butter in the refrigerator or on the kitchen counter if you prefer it at room temperature. These dishes are made of various materials and can hold at least one standard butter stick.

Keep reading as we bring you a selection of the top tried-and-tested butter dishes that are both functional and attractive. Give your butter a new home by choosing one of these.

In This Article

15 Best Butter Dishes

1. Best Non-Slip:Oxo Good Grips Butter Dish

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

Over 21,708 satisfied customers have left positive reviews about the product on Amazon.

This is one of the best plastic butter dishes with a lid and has stoppers on both ends to keep butter in place. The non-slip feet and tablespoon measurement markings add to the utility of this simple glass butter dish. Need more information? Watch this review video to make an informed decision about the transparent crystal butter dish.

Color: White/Clear | Material: Plastic | Item Weight: 5 ounces | Product Dimensions: 7.87 x 2.56 x 2 inches

Pros

  • Glass lid allows you to know the butter quantity inside
  • Ensures easy and mess-free cutting of butter
  • Unique design does not let the butter slip from the tray
  • Non-slip handles provide a secure grip
  • Dishwasher-safe

Cons

  • May not be a sturdy construction
  • May be small to hold a western butter stick

Our Tester's Experience

"I've been using this sleek butter dish for over a year. It is efficient in preserving butter and super easy to clean and maintain. The measuring lines are a smart addition."


protip_icon Quick tip

Place refrigerated butter in the butter dish and leave it on the kitchen counter to help it come to room temperature. Leave only as much butter as you can use within a day or two.

2. Best Sturdy:Butter Bell – The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain

Seal the freshness of your butter for long with this high-quality bone China classic butter bell crock. Fill its base with cold water, and you can store butter for up to 30 days without refrigeration. This matte-finished butter dish makes a beautiful addition to your tabletop or kitchen decor. The expert-approved elegant butter dish with french crock model also makes an amazing gift for butter lovers on special occasions. If you need further convincing, check out this YouTuber’s review.

Color: Aqua | Material: Ceramic | Item Weight: 1.78 pounds | Product Dimensions: 3.94 x 3.94 x 4.13 inches

Pros

  • Sturdy construction
  • Inverted bell-shaped lid
  • Keeps the butter soft and fresh
  • Comes in different colors
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Free of lead and cadmium
  • Comes with a two-year warranty

Cons

  • Can hold just one stick of butter
  • Chances of butter falling into cold water may be high
  • Requires replacement of water after every two or three days
Our Tester's Experience

"This ceramic butter crock keeps my butter soft and spreadable and effortlessly blends with my kitchen's decor, making it a practical and aesthetic choice. Plus, cleaning it is a breeze."

3. Best Easy-To-Use: Sweejar Ceramic Butter Dish

4.6
Sweejar Ceramic Butter Dish Image: Sweejar

Store your butter and keep it fresh in this cute dish by Sweejar! The lid is convenient as it fits well and has a handle that allows easy lifting. You don’t have to worry about the lid getting greasy or losing grip on the cover whenever you use it. Since the dish is 4.9 inches wide and 7.3 inches long, it can hold a large capacity of butter. This way, you don’t have to worry about the butter touching the sides of the dish or the cover. Thanks to the classic design of this square butter dish with a thick wall, it prevents the butter from getting hard when stored in the refrigerator.

Closure Material: Ceramic | Color: Turquoise | Material: Porcelain | Item Weight: 2.4 pounds

Pros

  • Available in various colors
  • Glossy finish
  • Lead-free and non-toxic
  • Microwave-safe

Cons

  • Platter may wobble on flat surfaces
  • May not be scratch-resistant

Our Tester's Experience

"This butter dish cozily houses a whole pound of butter, and the good news? I don't find myself digging around for butter anymore. The sturdy ceramic composition requires some careful handling though. Its stand-out feature, I would say, is the easy-to-grip handle on its lid—no more slippery butter-fingers."


Oxo Good Grips Butter Dish
Best Non-Slip
Butter Bell - The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain
Best Sturdy
Sweejar Ceramic Butter Dish
Best Easy-To-Use
Color White/Clear Aqua Turquoise
Material Plastic Ceramic Porcelain
Weight 5 ounces 1.78 pounds 2.4 pounds
Dimensions 7.87 x 2.56 x 2 inches 3.94 x 3.94 x 4.13 inches-
Closure Material-- Ceramic
Rating
Reviews21,7085,347161
Price$11.95$28.95$19.99

4. Best Freezer-Safe:KooK Ceramic Butter Dish with Handle Cover Design

This ceramic butter dish keeps your salted butter soft and easy-to-spread. It makes a convenient covered butter dish to store one standard butter stick. The classic white color and the unique design with the word “BUTTER” engraved on the lid complement most kitchen decors. This expert-approved traditional butter dish measures 7.5 x 3.75 x 3.5in.

Color: White | Material: Ceramic | Item Weight: 2.18 pounds | Product Dimensions: 7.5 x 3.75 x 3.5 inches

Pros

  • Easy-to-lift handle
  • Sturdy and durable construction
  • Rim on the cover protects it from slipping
  • Dishwasher-, microwave-, and freezer-safe
  • Inner ridge to keep butter in place
  • FDA-approved and lead-free

Cons

  • Lid may not offer airtight seal
  • Unglazed bottom may scratch tabletops

My Personal Experience

"The butter dish is aesthetically pleasing, and cleaning it is a breeze, as it can be washed in the dishwasher. I like that it can also be placed in the freezer and microwave, allowing me to use the butter in varied consistencies for different recipes."


protip_icon Quick fact

Unlike metal and plastic butter dishes, ceramic dishes are slow to warm, meaning butter stored in ceramic containers takes longer to reach room temperature.

5. Best Ceramic: Blue Rose Polish Pottery Butter Dish

4.9
Blue Rose Polish Pottery Butter Dish Image: Blue Rose Pottery

The beautiful butter dish will take your stoneware collection to the next level, while keeping your butter fresh! The butter dish by Blue Rose is handcrafted in Poland, which is why the East European style is pretty evident in its stellar quality and design. Each piece in the ceramic collection is unique since it is hand painted and has an artisan finish. The floral butter dish is easy to clean, microwave-safe, and can be stored in the fridge to keep the butter cool.

Color: Blue | Material: Stoneware, Ceramic, Stone | Item Weight: 2 pounds | Product Dimensions: 7.75 x 4.25 x 3 inches

Pros

  • Lead-free
  • Design won’t wear off
  • Cadmium-free
  • Dishwasher-safe

Cons

  • May get stained after prolonged use
  • May not be airtight

6. Best Fade-Resistant:Dowan Porcelain Butter Dish

4.5

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

More than 12,424 buyers on Amazon have said the product lives up to the hype.

This butter dish offers a generous space to fit all kinds of western and eastern butter sticks. The quality-tested porcelain Dowan butter dish is extremely durable and resistant to fading, chipping, or cracking. The wooden lid with silicone seal ensures a perfect snap closure to keep the butter fresh. The Dowan butter dish measures 5.7 x 3.4 x 2.87in.

Color: White | Material: Porcelain, Wooden | Item Weight: 1.82 pounds | Product Dimensions: 6.5 x 4 x 3.1 inches

Pros

  • Depth prevents the butter from sticking on the lid
  • Multipurpose; can be used for storing various other things
  • Microwave-, freezer-, oven-, and dishwasher-safe
  • Silicone seal ring protects butter from odor
  • Available in six different colors to complement your kitchen top

Cons

  • Wooden lid requires handwashing
  • Depth may make it tough to get the butter
Our Tester's Experience

"The butter dish impressed me not only with its sleek design but also with its snug lid. It protects my grass-fed butter from light and unwanted elements. The fine wooden lid and ceramic body give it a farmhouse finish. The weight of the container makes handling it a bit tricky though."

7. Best Easy-To-Clean:Better Dish Flip Top Butter Dish

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

The product has earned its stripes, with over 2,163 reviews on Amazon.

It is a convenient butter dish that lets you enjoy spreadable butter without any mess. The plastic dish comes with an exclusive flip-top lid attachment and roomy interiors to hold up to two butter sticks. The easy-to-snap lids with a bumper on the back add to its functionality.

Closure Material: Plastic | Color: Red | Material: Plastic | Item Weight: 7.4 ounces

Pros

  • Single-piece construction takes little space
  • Has a compact design
  • Durable and sturdy design
  • Safe to use in microwave and dishwasher
  • Easy-grip handles and non-slip base
  • Convenient and easy-to-clean lid

Cons

  • Flip-top lid may not be sturdy
Our Tester's Experience

"This one-of-its-kind butter dish is designed to store butter without dirtying the lid that stays secure in one place. I love its textured bottom and sturdy plastic build. I own two of these, and I can vouch for their longevity."

8. Best Lightweight:Cooler Kitchen Modern Bamboo Dark Grey Butter Dish With Lid

4.4

Choose this eco-friendly and durable Bamboo butter dish with a roomy design to store butter of all kinds. The contemporary Scandinavian design makes it a beautiful addition to any kitchen decor. Designed with ridges on the sides, this expert-recommended modern butter dish by Cooler Kitchen protects your cool butter from touching the sides or slipping out.

Closure Material: Bamboo | Color: Gray | Material: Bamboo | Item Weight: 9.5 ounces

Pros

  • Lightweight and durable oval butter dish
  • Dishwasher- and microwave-safe
  • Can also fit tall butter sticks

Cons

  • Material may absorb oil
Our Tester's Experience

"With its generous size and elegant shape, this dish is a welcome change from our regular butter dish. The one missing feature is a handle, which would have been handy. Nevertheless, I would still recommend this unit for its ability to keep the butter fresh and for its minimalistic vibes."

9. Best Non-Toxic: Le Creuset Stoneware European Butter Dish

4.7
Le Creuset Stoneware European Butter Dish Image: Le Creuset

The heavy-duty and high-quality material of the butter dish sets it apart. Since it is stoneware, it’s effective at moisture absorption, preventing any cracking, rippling, or crazing after long-term use. The raised edges ensure your butter stays in place and doesn’t flow out when it’s melted. Additionally, the exterior enamel of this rustic butter dish is impermeable and resists stains or scratches.

Color: Cerise | Material: Stoneware | Item Weight: 2.3 pounds | Product Dimensions: 6.75 x 5 x 3.5 inches

Pros

  • Available in two vibrant colors
  • Non-stick glaze
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • High heat-resistant

Cons

  • Lid may have a wobbly fit
  • Some may find the dish bigger than expected

Our Tester's Experience

"This beauty accommodates two standard-sized butter sticks and fits well in my fridge door. It is pleasing to the eye and practical with a handy handle."


10. Best Design: MyGift White Ceramic Farmhouse Butter Dish

4.6

The regal-looking butter dish by MyGift has a minimal design and glossy white color. It has an eye-catching feature in the form of a little bird handle, which is cute and functional. The dish will keep your butter fresh and at room temperature so that you can host guests easily. This decorative butter dish also makes for a great housewarming gift.

Color: White | Material: Ceramic | Item Weight: 1 pounds | Product Dimensions: 6.5 x 3 x 4 inches

Pros

  • Easy to clean
  • Durable
  • Available in two colors
  • Makes for a great countertop decoration

Cons

  • Some may find the size small
  • Some may find it slippery

Our Tester's Experience

"I have owned several butter dishes, but none match this adorable one in terms of cuteness and practicality. The bird on the lid is not just a design but a useful handle. Also, it is dishwasher-safe."


11. Best Elegant: Lenox French Perle Covered Butter Dish

4.6

Gift your family or loved ones this pristine butter dish, especially if it’s a wedding or housewarming occasion. This tried-and-tested french butter dish by Lenox is made from durable stoneware. Since it’s microwave-safe, you don’t have to worry about the color coming off when heated or any scratches. Its rim features a hand-applied tea satin finish, giving the french butter keeper a sophisticated aesthetic look.

Color: White | Material: Stoneware | Item Weight: 1.25 pounds | Product Dimensions: 7.25 x 3 x 3.5 inches

Pros

  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Well-crafted
  • Adequate capacity
  • Platter won’t wobble on flat surfaces

Cons

  • May not have color options
  • Glossy finish may fade with time

My Personal Experience

"Although it's a bit smaller than I had expected, I am quite satisfied with its elegance and sturdy build. It is suitable for both everyday use and festive occasions and complements my existing crockery sets."


12. Best Dishwasher-Safe:Creative Co-op Stoneware Butter Dish

4.7
Creative Co-op Stoneware Butter Dish Image: Image: Creativeco-op
Now 64% Off

This stoneware butter dish by Creative Co-Op comes with a convenient lid and is sturdily built to last you for years. Its sturdy plate base has protective walls that make it stable. The vintage-design butter dish measures 6.75 x 4.5 x 3.75in, and you can use it to store butter and butter sticks.

Color: White | Material: Stoneware | Item Weight: 1.6 pounds | Product Dimensions: 6.75 x 4.5 x 3.75 inches

Pros

  • Microwave- and dishwasher-safe
  • Comes with a flat bottom
  • Enough space for butter
  • Lid has a handle for convenience

Cons

  • May not be durable
Our Tester's Experience

"This one has everything I love in a butter dish. Its farmhouse look and handle make it my favorite. The dish accommodates most standard butter blocks and conceals any buttery mess with its heavy-duty lid."

13. Best Long-Lasting: Home Acre Designs Butter Dish

4.6
Home Acre Designs Butter Dish Image: Home Acre Designs

If you are looking for a butter dish that is long-lasting and will keep your salted or unsalted butter fresh, the butter keeper by Home Acre might be suitable. The stainless steel material has a smudge-resistant design that won’t chip away or break, making it suitable for butter lovers. Also, since the platter is deep, you don’t have to worry about butter sticking to the lid, thanks to the 6x4x2.5-inch frame.

Color: White | Material: Steel | Item Weight: 14 ounces | Product Dimensions: 6 x 4 x 2.5 inches

Pros

  • Platter doubles as a cutting board lid
  • Durable stainless steel butter dish
  • Can store up to two sticks of butter
  • Made from natural bamboo

Cons

  • Cursive writing may fade after a few washes
  • May not be microwave-safe

Our Tester's Experience

"For anyone looking for a durable stainless steel butter dish with the looks of a ceramic dish, this is it. It fits butter sticks of most popular brands, and the dish doubles as a cutting board."


14. Best Polished: Priority Chef Ceramic Butter Dish

4.6
Priority Chef Ceramic Butter Dish Image: Prioritychef

The modern and simple butter dish will keep your butter soft and fresh for a long time. Since it holds one butter stick, it is designed to be convenient, keeping the contents safe, allowing easy cleaning, maintenance. This contemporary butter dish enables effortless scraping, so you don’t have to worry about leftovers or greasy residue. The pearly white color and polished finish look great on any kitchen countertop and make a classy addition to the family’s kitchen.

Shape: Rectangular | Closure Material: Ceramic | Color: White | Material: Ceramic | Item Weight: 1.94 pounds

Pros

  • Sturdy
  • Wide platter
  • Suitable for narrow countertops
  • Safe for dishwasher, oven, microwave, and freezer

Cons

  • May stain yellow after prolonged use
  • May spill over the edges

Our Tester's Experience

"The dish arrived with a slightly rough bottom, risking scratches on my table. However, a little DIY polishing resolved this tiny hiccup. It is a worthwhile find owing to its practical features—a handled lid and a bottom with raised edges for keeping the lid in place."


15. Best Lead-Free: Bezrat Glass Butter Dish

4.6

The gorgeous butter dish is made from high-quality glass and looks beautiful on any countertop or dining table. Display your butter stick neatly with this rectangular dish and keep it in one place with a sturdy cover that will hold its shape. This transparent butter keeper is safe to use and is free of lead and toxins. The classy design is elevated thanks to the textured lid with an engraved surface.

Color: Clear | Material: Glass | Item Weight: 8 ounces | Product Dimensions: 7 x 4 x 3 inches

Pros

  • Offers clear visibility
  • Easy to hold
  • Vintage butter dish
  • Dishwasher-safe

Cons

  • May get warped
  • Lid may not sit properly at the base

Our Tester's Experience

"The transparent glass of this dish lets me easily assess the quantity of the remaining butter, while the "Butter" label helps my children not to mistake it for margarine. Although it doesn't feature a handle, its lid is easy to grip and remove."


*The prices provided in this article are based on the latest available information. However, they may vary due to changes in pricing by the seller and/or promotional offers.

How To Choose The Right Butter Dish?

Here are some product specifications to consider while shopping for the best butter dish.

  1. Size: Every butter keeper comes with different storage capacity, and depending on your requirements, you must look into what size will be suitable for you and your family.
  2. Material: Butter dishes are made of glass, plastic, stainless steel, ceramic, bamboo, etc. You must go with the material that is expert-recommended, durable, free of health hazards, and easy to clean.
  3. Design: Butter keepers come in different designs, ranging from vintage to contemporary, and decorative to functional. Pick the one that matches your kitchen interiors.
  4. Ease of handling: Always pick a butter dish that is convenient to handle and easy to wash to save your time and efforts.

Akino Ogata, a Japanese food expert, says, As I am a professional pastry chef, I give importance to how I store my butter. I store my butter refrigerated in air-tight containers to keep its freshness and fragrance intact for longer.”

She adds, “When choosing a butter dish, determine how often you use butter and how you like it. If you want your butter to have a soft consistency to make a sandwich or to spread on soft bread, keep it at room temperature. However, if you want to use it on toast, you can keep it in a fridge. As for the design, there are a lot of attractive products to choose from but stick to those that are functional.”

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Do butter dishes keep butter fresh?

Yes, butter dishes keep the salted or unsalted butter fresh when placed away from direct sunlight.

2. Do butter dishes keep butter soft?

If you leave the butter dish out at room temperature, it keeps the butter soft and fresh for up to two days.

3. How long can butter stay in a butter dish?

Butter, when refrigerated in an airtight seal container or butter dish, will stay fresh for up to two weeks or more. Leaving the butter dish out on the countertop for too many days may not spoil the butter, but it may turn rancid and unfresh.

4. Can I put butter dishes in the refrigerator?

Yes, most butter dishes are safe to store in a refrigerator unless it is mentioned otherwise by the manufacturer.

5. Does a butter dish need to be airtight?

Expert-recommended airtight butter dishes can keep the butter fresh for a longer duration than regular butter dishes.

The Bottom Line

To ensure that your butter remains fresh and the taste remains intact, you need to purchase the best butter dishes in the market. Made of durable materials, they stylishly complement any kitchen décor. When picking the ideal butter dish, ensure it is made of durable materials, free of health hazards, and easy to clean. Also, look for one that is easy to use, pleasant to look at, and features easy-grip handles and a non-slip base. Our top choices include the Blue Rose Polish Pottery Butter Dish for its elegance and durability and the Le Creuset Stoneware European Butter Dish for its moisture-absorbing properties. The Sweejar Ceramic Butter Dish also makes a good pick for being lead-free and non-toxic.

Infographic: Things To Look For In A Butter Dish

Butter can easily get melted or hardened if not kept in good condition. A butter dish is a simple yet important kitchen item that helps keep butter fresh and spreadable. Check out the infographic below to explore some useful tips you should keep in mind when choosing a butter dish for your kitchen.

Tips For Choosing A Right Butter Dish (infographic)

Illustration: Momjunction Design Team

Get the high-quality PDF version of this infographic.

Download Infographic in PDF version


Recommended Articles

Why Trust MomJunction?

Sakshi John, the author of this article, is a kitchen and home decor enthusiast. She loves to cook and try out the best kitchen products that make cooking a breeze. Sakshi relies on her years of expertise and extensive research on product guidelines, user reviews, and feedback to bring out her buying guide and list of the best butter dishes for you that are both functional and attractive.

Was this article helpful?
thumbsupthumbsdown
The following two tabs change content below.