11 Best Eye Makeup For Sensitive Eyes To Look Good In 2022


Eye makeup can be a troublesome job for people who have sensitive eyes. But even they long to achieve those extra-winged eye-lines and dramatic eyes but usually don’t have the best eye makeup for sensitive eyes. Thus, it often leads to itchiness and redness around their eyes. Finding and sticking to eye makeup products safe for sensitive eye people can make a huge difference in resolving their eye makeup issues.

Check out our list of the best eye makeup for sensitive eyes, and look through their pros and cons to pick one for yourself.

11 Best Eye Makeup For Sensitive Eyes

The manufacturers or brands may claim their products are suitable for sensitive eyes. But as a careful buyer, you should know about the ingredients and understand which ones may cause you irritation. Read the label and then make a purchase.

1. Best Long-Lasting:Physicians Formula Eye Enhancing Kit

Physicians Formula Eye Enhancing Kit

The nude makeup kit that comes with two mascaras, two eyeliners, and an eye shadow palette with nine shades. All of them are formulated using natural ingredients and do not contain any harsh chemicals. They can be used by people with sensitive skin and those who wear contact lenses.


  • Long-lasting wear
  • Hypoallergenic and tested
  • Recommended by dermatologists, allergists, and ophthalmologists


  • Mascara may dry quickly
  • The kit may seem too small

2. Best Smudge-Resistant:Physicians Formula Eyeliner And Serum

Physicians Formula Eyeliner And Serum

A two-in-one makeup product for sensitive skin, this liquid eyeliner plus eyelash serum is a high-tech Japanese formula to give a beautiful look to your eyes. It is hypoallergenic and formulated without any harmful substances. The product is available in two colors, black and dark brown. This video review will help you learn more about the product.


  • Dermatologist-approved
  • Water and smudge-resistant
  • Nourishing and long-wearing


  • Not highly-pigmented

3. Best Easy-To-Blend:Burt’s Bees Eye Shadow Palette

Burt’s Bees Eye Shadow Palette

Formulated with natural ingredients such as vitamins, honey, and bamboo, which is delicate on your eyes, this product is gentle on the skin and the eyes. It is free from parabens, synthetic fragrances, phthalates, talc, petroleum, silicones, and SLS. It comes in four shades, including shimmering nudes, countryside lavender, dusky woods, and blooming desert.


  • Gentle and long-lasting formula
  • Easy-to-blend and smudge-free
  • Nourishing mineral formula


  • Too powdery and may flake

4. Best Water-Proof:Physicians Formula Eye Pencil

Physicians Formula Eye Pencil

Soft on the eye, this eye pencil smoothly glides to give you a clean stroke. This makeup product for sensitive eyes is free from any harmful chemicals. It comes with a sharpener and is easy to apply.


  • Hypoallergenic and cruelty-free
  • Dermatologist-approved
  • Waterproof formula


  • Too dry and may not last for long

5. Best Hypoallergenic:Jolie Mascara

Jolie Mascara

Made for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, this mascara is gentle on the eyes. The water-soluble formula can be applied and removed easily. It comes in three colors, including black, black and brown, and navy blue. The mascara comes in a sleek oval-shaped black bottle.


  • Non-irritating and fragrance-free
  • Gentle and hypoallergenic
  • Provides natural-looking lashes


  • It does not last for long

6. Best Fragnance-Free:La Roshe Posay Toleriane Mascara

La Roshe Posay Toleriane Mascara

This mascara is suitable for sensitive eyes as it is free from fragrance and parabens. The product is ophthalmologist- and allergy-tested and adds volume to your lashes. The product is formulated with jojoba oil that provides comfort to your eyes. This video will help you make an informed decision about your purchase.


  • Waterproof formula
  • Offers three-dimensional volume to lashes
  • Jojoba oil nourishes the eyelashes


  • May get smudged

7. Best Flake-Free:Laudée Mascara

Laudée Mascara

The long-lasting mascara comes with a curve comb and curls your lashes, giving them a beautiful effect. Its gentle formula is based on three-dimensional microfibers to make your lashes look longer and dramatic. It is easy to apply and remove and provides deep pigmentation.


  • Waterproof and hypoallergenic
  • Deeply pigmented and flake-free
  • Provides thicker, voluminous, and longer lashes


  • Too thick and may dry quickly

8. Best Latex-Free:Davocy Eyelash Glue

Davocy Eyelash Glue

Want to make your eyelashes extra-long? Use this eyelash glue to attach fake lashes safely. This enables quick and convenient application and can be easily removed using a makeup remover. The glue is latex-free and is safe to use for sensitive eyes and is suitable for all types of lashes.


  • Gentle, odor and formaldehyde-free
  • Gets transparent in a few seconds


  • May not last for long

9. Best Sweat-Proof:Cherisher Mascara

Cherisher Mascara

This mascara contains vitamin E complex that provides volume and length to your lashes. It comes with a curvy brush that offers a natural curvature to your eyelashes. The product contains a vitamin complex to offer nourishment and does not include harmful chemicals to keep your lashes safe.


  • Made with natural and tested ingredients
  • Provides long-wear
  • Water-resistant, sweatproof, and hypoallergenic


  • Too thick and may flake

10. Best Allergy-Tested:La Roshe Posay Respectissime Liquid Eyeliner

La Roshe Posay Respectissime Liquid Eyeliner

Formulated using natural wax, this liquid eyeliner is suitable for contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eyes. Its tip provides easy application and adds an intense effect to your eyes. Its natural wax formula helps you have clean lines in just one stroke and also protects sensitive eyes from drying.


  • Ultra-flexible tip brush
  • Paraben and fragrance-free, and allergy-tested
  • Provides precise and clean lines


  • Could dry too quickly

11. Best Cruelty-Free:Skin2Spirit Natural Eyeliner Pencil

Skin2Spirit Natural Eyeliner Pencil

This eyeliner pencil is formulated with botanical ingredients and healing oils such as castor oil, jojoba oil, shea butter, and cocoa butter. It goes smooth and soft on your sensitive eyes. It can be removed easily too. The product is free from harmful chemicals and suitable for sensitive skin.


  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Long-lasting and hypoallergenic
  • Available in two colors, black and brown


  • Not smudge-free

How To Choose The Right Makeup For Sensitive Eyes?

If you have sensitive eyes, you should not pick just any eye makeup. Keep these tips in mind to choose safe eye makeup products for yourself.

  1. Ingredients: When you have sensitive eyes, you should always read the label to check for the ingredients. Go with products that are formulated with natural ingredients and are free from harmful chemicals, parabens, sulfates, petroleum, and fragrances.
  1. Brands: Look for brands whose products have been recommended by dermatologists and tested as per the standards. Most of the brands manufacture hypoallergenic products that are safe and non-irritating for eye makeup. Some well-known brands are cruelty-free and formulate vegan products only.
  1. Skin type: You should also choose eye makeup products based on your skin type. If you have sensitive and oily skin, then you should not use products formulated for dry skin. Do figure out what suits you and what doesn’t, and then pick up the products.
  1. Patch test: If you have sensitive skin, you need to do a patch test even when you buy products from reputable brands. After performing a patch test, wait for 48 to 72 hours and then use the product if there are no side-effects.

Why Trust MomJunction?

Poulami Nag is a product writer with expertise in skincare and beauty products. She understands the struggle of people with sensitive eyes in finding the right makeup. Hence, she has put together a list of the best eye makeups, along with their formulations and detailed descriptions about their use, advantages, and disadvantages. You can select the right one for yourself with the help of the buying guide provided here.

Applying makeup is nothing less than an art, where your skin is the canvas. Makeup kits are available for different skin types, including sensitive skin. The best eye makeup products are carefully formulated to be gentle on the skin and not cause irritation to the eyes. In addition, they are made of natural ingredients and are hypoallergenic, water-resistant, and smudge-resistant. Before using any product on the eyes, it is always advisable to do a patch test and consult your ophthalmologist and dermatologist.

Recommended Articles:

Was this article helpful?
The following two tabs change content below.

Poulami Nag

Poulami Nag is a writer and associate editor at MomJunction. She did her MA in English from Miranda House, University of Delhi and has qualified UGC-NET. Her journey as a content writer began in 2017 and since then she has garnered diverse interests along the way. Her knowledge of literature and language has given her an eye for detail and... more