Research-backed
Image: MomJunction Design Team
If you want your eyelashes to look denser and more voluminous, you should try the best fiber mascara available. With silk, rayon, and nylon fibers, these makeup artist-approved fiber mascaras do a smooth and effortless job of dressing up your eyes with every swipe. In addition, they do not cause smudging and are infused with natural ingredients for conditioning your lashes. Check out our reviews of the top fiber mascaras to pick one and flaunt long lashes.
Top Picks
14 Best Fiber Mascaras For Eyelashes, For An Extra-Long Look
1. Best Overall: Mia Adora 400X Fiber Lash Mascara
Image: Miaadore The fiber lashes mascara from Mia Adora provides helps enhance lash volume and length. This long-lasting fiber mascara gives you ultra-black eyelashes and is smudge-proof, easy to apply, instant, and waterproof. The kit includes a tube of magnifying gel, micro-lash extensions, and a mascara tube. This fiber mascara can make your eyelashes 400% thicker. You can watch this review video to understand how the product works before buying.
Pros
- Non-toxic and clump-free mascara formula
- Guarantees a three-step application
- Parabens-, SLS-, and cruelty-free
- Comes with a detailed set of instructions
Cons
- Mascara formula might get flakey
- When put on lashes, the product feels hard
"Applying this mascara is a breeze with the included separating brush. It enables even coating, leaving me with flawless, natural-looking lashes. Just a little patience is all it takes to achieve the desired look."
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
Over 12,768 satisfied customers have left positive reviews about the product on Amazon.
2. Best For Thicker Lashes: Bestidy 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara
Image: Bestidy Bestidy’s 4D fiber mascara is infused with gentle and organic ingredients. In addition to the incredible length and volume, it also gives you well-defined eyelashes and makes them thicker and fuller. The natural fiber mascara lasts all day long, and the formula is creamy and smooth–it sets on your lashes without clumping or leaving any flakes, offering visible results. This waterproof and nourishing mascara can make your eyelashes long and beautiful even in rain or sweat.
Pros
- Can be easily removed using warm water
- Contains gentle and natural ingredients
- Curl-locking mascara
- Has a soft fiber brush
- Suitable for people with sensitive skin
- Not tested on animals
Cons
- Has a sticky consistency
- Might give you short and chunky lashes
- Dries fast, making the second application tougher
"Despite occasional clumps, this mascara's staying power has blown my mind. It stays put throughout the day, even in intense humidity. Plus, it smoothly comes off with my oil-based remover without causing any sensitivities to my eyes."
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
The whopping 10,625 positive reviews on Amazon reflect the superior quality of this product.
3. Best Cruelty-Free: Elizabeth Mott It’s So Big Volumizing Mascara
Image: Elizabeth Mott Formulated with flexible tubing polymers, this result-driven volumizing black mascara has a corset-shaped brush that evenly coats your eyelashes and makes them look voluminous without clumping. This cruelty-free mascara is infused with a blend of natural carnauba and beeswax to keep your lashes curled all day. Furthermore, the long-wear fiber technology makes this mascara resistant to wear, tear, and sweat.
Pros
- Water-based, lightweight formula
- Smudge-proof
- Safe for use on lash extensions
- Paraben-free formula
- Nourishing mascara
- Water-resistant formula
Cons
- Might be slightly difficult to remove
- Might flake
"I like the look of my lashes whenever I put this mascara on. It gives me a fuller look and stays put all day without smudging. Application can be a bit messy, so I'd suggest being patient with it."
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
The 5,194 positive customer reviews on Amazon attest to the product’s quality.
Mia Adora 400X Fiber Lash Mascara Best Overall | Bestidy 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara Best For Thicker Lashes | Elizabeth Mott It’s So Big Volumizing Mascara Best Cruelty-Free | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Color | Ultra Carbon Black | black | Black |
| Package Dimensions | 6.5 x 2.7 x 1.2 inches; 4.8 Ounces | 5.16 x 1.26 x 0.87 inches; 1.13 Ounces | - |
| Dimensions | - | - | 4.8 x 0.7 x 0.7 inches |
| Weight | - | - | 0.64 Ounces |
| Rating | |||
| Reviews | 12,768 | 10,625 | 5,194 |
| Price | $17.88 | $9.99 | $11.99 |
4. Best With Primer: L’Oreal Paris X Fiber Mascara
Image: L'oreal Paris Improve lash volume and length with this dual-function L’Oreal Paris mascara. The single bottle comprises a black primer at one end and a fiber mascara at the other. Start by applying the fiber mascara primer for instant and intense volume, then follow up with the mascara for fuller lashes and a more dramatic finish. You can eliminate the inconvenience of wearing and removing extensions or false eyelashes with this celebrity-endorsed mascara.
Pros
- Easy to apply
- Smudge-proof
- Water-resistant formula
- Anti-panda eyes removal
Cons
- Some may find it dry
- May get clumpy
Quick tip5. Best Smudge-proof Fiber Mascara: Tetyana Naturals 4D Silk Fiber Mascara
Image: Neenoxtub The fiber lengthening mascara from Tetyana Naturals is perfect for people with sensitive skin. This waterproof and fiber-infused mascara will give you a dramatic extension. Use this fiber mascara with lash-boosting ingredients for enhanced lash volume and get rich, dark, and beautiful lashes. You can also wear this mascara with contact lenses. The non-toxic and natural formula is safe for the eyes. The product guarantees a natural look. Not sure if this is the right fit for you? Check out this review video to understand how the product works.
Pros
- Won’t smudge or clump on your natural lashes
- Has a feathery, soft, and smooth formula
- Hypoallergenic formula
- Long-lasting
- Deeply pigmented black water-resistant mascara
Cons
- Has a heavy formula
- Might not suit people with oily skin
- The application might lead to “spider-leg” lashes
6. Best Lightweight:Maybelline New York Illegal Length Mascara
Image: Maybelline Maybelline New York’s Illegal Length mascara has a non-clumping formula that gives a lifted appearance to the natural lashes. Its unique blend stretches the lashes and makes them appear 4 mm longer with just one application. The professional-grade mascara comes with an enhanced fiber-fix brush and easy-grip mascara wand, enabling you to coat even the tiniest lashes in just a few strokes. Additionally, it is suitable for daily wear, as it is washable and adheres to lashes without breaking or flaking.
Pros
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Feels light on the lashes
- Has a soft and skinny brush
- Contact lens-safe
Cons
- May dry out over time
- May not be water-resistant
"This mascara has been a decent choice for my everyday smudge-free look. It offers good length to the lashes and a slight volume, too, especially when I pair it with a little primer. Also, it applies smoothly and comes off without any hassle."
Quick tip7. Best Lightweight:Wet N Wild Lash-O-Matic Mascara + Fiber Extension Kit
Image: Wet N Wild This vegan fiber mascara set from the tried-and-tested Wet N Wild brand is a safe and healthy choice for your eyelashes. First, apply the black gel to your natural lashes, then add the lightweight nylon fibers, and reapply the gel to seal them in place. The lightweight formula is comfortable to wear and long-lasting, ensuring your lashes stay voluminous and luscious all day.
Pros
- Cruelty-free
- Vegan
- Paraben-free
- Smudge-resistant
- Adds volume and length
Cons
- May be difficult to remove
- May become clumpy
"Just a couple of swipes of this mascara and lash fibers provide a fuller look to my lashes. Their dense brushes simplify the application process, but removing the product requires patience. Still, it's an excellent option compared to false lashes and the hassles that come with them."
Do remember8. Best Fiber Mascara for Curling: Nuonove Funfunman 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara
This set of three fiber eyelash extension mascaras is waterproof and ideal for women with sensitive skin. It is intensely pigmented and will give you beautiful and dramatic eyelashes with one application. The tried-and-tested product stays all day long without clumping, flaking, or drying out the skin. It is easy to remove, and the creamy and smooth texture is effortless to sweep through the eyelashes. The hypoallergenic fiber formulas will not irritate your eyes. This beauty product can be worn even with your contact lenses on.
Pros
- Has a soft and smooth silicone applicator
- Curling fiber mascara
- Hypoallergenic formula
- Gives instant results in just a single coat
- Can be washed off with warm water as well
- Stays all day long, even during rain, sweat, or tears
Cons
- The smudge-proof feature is not up to the mark
- Has a watery consistency
- Might clump almost instantly
"The unique formula of this mascara truly stands out. It elegantly flakes off in water, making it a complete breeze to remove. It's not entirely waterproof, thus calling for occasional touch-ups."
9. Best For Instant Definition:Essence What the Fake! Fiber Mascara
Image: Essence If you want to get the voluminous false lash look minus the elaborate process of having them, the Essence What the Fake! fiber mascara can come to your rescue. Its thick and pigmented formula shows visible results by defining the lashes instantly. It can also be used as a stand-alone product or be added as a layer to achieve maximum volume. Further, it comes with a nylon-bristled double-tapered brush to help you to apply a thick yet even coat of the product.
Pros
- Paraben-free
- Cruelty-free
- Free of artificial fragrances
- Easy to use
- Buildable
Cons
- May be a non-waterproof formula
- Some may not like the thick consistency
"I'm genuinely pleased with this mascara's efficiency. It adds both length and volume and stays put for hours. It also feels gentle on my lashes and has been my trusted choice for everyday use."
10. Best Flake-Free: Toullgo 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara
Toullgo Store’s fiber mascara is smudge-proof and ensures that it does not clump. It is suitable for dry skin types and can increase the length and volume of the eyelashes by up to 300%. This dramatic fiber mascara is long-lasting, giving you a stunning look all day long. It can easily be removed with a makeup cleanser or warm water. You can wear this beauty product on any occasion, be it weddings, parties, or workplaces.
Pros
- Flake-free and consists of smooth and creamy fiber formulas
- Deeply pigmented
- Waterproof formula
- Delivers dramatic finish
- Suitable for everyday wear
- Gives immediate results
Cons
- Mascara has a thin consistency
- Requires multiple application
"This mascara duo helps me achieve a dramatic look by adding more body to my lashes. The application was slightly challenging, but once I got the hang of it, it was pretty smooth. It certainly is a decent pick for everyday use."
11. Best Volumizing:St. Mege Silk Fiber Lash Mascara
Image: St. Mege The St. Mege set includes two tubes — one with a waterproof mascara gel and the other with lengthening fibers. Being sweat-proof, it applies smoothly, and the dry fibers apply on top of the wet mascara to give your lashes a boost in length and volume. The gel then seals the fibers in place to keep them from smudging. Made with natural ingredients, it is gentle on the eyes and does not trigger irritation, making it a safe fiber mascara for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic
- Smudge-proof
- Waterproof
- Easy to remove
- Does not need re-application
Cons
- Process may be a bit time consuming
- May get clumpy if not applied with precision
"After trying out various mascaras, I've finally found this one that has simplified my beauty routine. It's completely smudge-free and adds enough volume, eliminating the need for false lashes. The bonus is that it's contact lens-friendly."
12. Best Safe Ingredients: EpiLynx Extreme Volume And Length Mascara With Eyelash Primer
Image: Epilynx Enriched with the goodness of green tea fibers, this mascara and primer duo by EpiLynx is formulated to bestow a bold 3D volume to your eyelashes. It also contains synthetic collagen that gives your lashes a natural lift while providing a sophisticated finish. In addition, the sleek and flexible mascara wand ensures complete and hassle-free coverage. This hypoallergenic fiber mascara is suitable for most skin types.
Pros
- Vegan-friendly
- Not tested on animals
- Nut- and gluten-free
- Free of harsh chemicals and phthalates
- Free of GMO ingredients
Cons
- May not be contact-lens-friendly
- May dry up faster than expected
13. Best Drugstore Fiber Mascara: Maybelline New York Gigi Hadid Fiber Mascara
Maybelline New York’s fiber extension mascara will give you elongated lashes in three easy steps. This drugstore fiber lashes mascara has a dual-ended brush for a voluminous and fuller look. With this mascara, you can achieve supermodel-worthy lashes for any occasion, including a wedding, party, event, workplace, or even a nightclub. As per reviews, the product is smudge-proof and works well in just one stroke.
Pros
- Can easily be removed with a makeup remover
- Deeply pigmented
- Stays all day long
- Long-wearing mascara
- Adds decent volume to the lashes
Cons
- Might dry out soon
- Might flake during the day
"This mascara lets me have well-defined, long lashes, exactly how I like for occasions and parties. Its lasting ability is also impressive. Remember, restraint is key, as it requires a light hand—too much can lead to clumps."
14. Best Safe To Use: Secret Xpress Control 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara
Image: Secret Xpress This 4D fiber mascara can add volume and increase the length of your eyelashes. It is suitable for all skin types and skin tones. This product’s mascara extension fiber will give you a glamorous look all day long. The doctor-recommended eye makeup product is straightforward to use, whether you are a beginner or a professional, and you can easily wash it off with warm water or a facial cleanser. The lashes stay fresh all day. This product is also suitable for people who wear contact lenses.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic mascara with non-irritating ingredients
- Smudge-proof and waterproof
- Won’t flake during the day
- Safe for your natural eyelashes
Cons
- Has a runny consistency
- Might dry very fast on the lashes and would instantly clump
"I must say, this mascara's resilience against weather conditions is really impressive. It doesn't flake or smudge and lasts longer than I expect. Removal is a breeze when I use the right makeup remover."
How To Choose The Right Fiber Mascara?
Consider the following factors before selecting the best fiber mascara.
1. Waterproof: Waxes and mineral oils in these mascaras aid in the retention of fiber formulas on the lashes. People can use this mascara all day, regardless of their skin type.
2. Curling: A curl-locking mascara is an iconic mascara. Curling your lashes can help you increase their volume, length, and intensity. Mascara fiber formulas will give you a noticeable curl.
3. Brush style: A thick brush would add volume and length, while other brushes work better on the roots. If the bristles in the brushes are spaced together, they will add definition to the lashes, whereas if they are spaced apart, they will create volume.
4. 3D or 4D fiber mascara: 3D mascaras are similar to your standard mascara. Their formula has a fluid-like consistency, and they are easier to apply. 4D silk mascaras contain a cream that also includes a magnifying gel. They add definition and volume, but they clump more easily.
Simone de Vlaming, a beauty expert and beauty blogger, says, “Fiber mascara can be a great option if you are looking to add volume and length to your lashes. Choose a high-quality fiber mascara that is designed to be gentle on the eyes and follow the instructions provided by the manufacturer for best results.”
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is fiber mascara safe?
Yes, good-quality fiber mascaras are safe to use. Fiber mascara formulas contain natural or synthetic fibers and are easy to remove. However, the fibers may flake and fall off in your eyes. Further, they should be washed off before sleeping. So look for a doctor-recommended mascara.
2. How should I apply mascara for best results?
For visible results, start applying the mascara from the roots and extend the brush to the ends. You can add more coats until you achieve the desired thickness.
3. How long does fiber mascara last?
A good-quality mascara may last a whole day when applied correctly. The lasting capacity of mascara may vary with the formula.
4. Can I use fiber mascara if I have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses?
Yes, most fiber mascaras are safe to wear with contact lenses and for those with sensitive eyes. However, it is very important to check the product specifications to ensure the product’s safety.
5. How should I remove fiber mascara?
You can use a soaked cotton pad to remove fiber mascara. Leave the soaked cotton pad on the lashes for about half a second and then wipe the lashes clean. Avoid tugging and pulling the lashes.
Why Trust MomJunction?
A fashion and makeup enthusiast, Poulami Nag is also a passionate writer who incorporates her expertise in beauty and skin care in her writing. She has researched several product reviews to compile this list of the best fiber mascaras for eyelashes, along with their pros and cons. These products ensure your lashes look voluminous and stunning for a long time.
Fiber mascaras are ideal for those who do not want extensions or a complete set of false eyelashes. Providing salon-like effects, these mascaras can give your lashes a natural lift while adding the right amount of volume. Not only are they cost-effective, but they are also smudge-proof, easy to apply, and contain non-toxic ingredients. If you’re wondering how to choose the best fiber mascara, check whether it’s waterproof, curl-locking, and comes with a suitable brush for application. In addition, a dermatologically approved mascara would be a best bet.
Infographic: What Not To Do When Applying Mascara?
The art of applying mascara requires a delicate balance between enhancing lashes and avoiding pitfalls. With precision and technique, mascara can beautifully transform eyes, adding depth and allure. Explore the infographic below to learn about common mistakes to avoid for an efficient mascara application.
Illustration: Momjunction Design Team
References
- Eye Cosmetic Safety; FDA
https://www.fda.gov/cosmetics/cosmetic-products/eye-cosmetic-safety
Recommended Articles
- Best Under-Eye Rollers
- Best Under-Eye Brightening Powders
- Best Eye Masks For Dark Circles
- Best Anti-Wrinkle Under Eye Creams
