11 Best Pacifiers For Breastfed Baby In 2024, Lactation Consultant-Reviewed

Choosing the best pacifier for breastfed babies can be a tricky affair. However, we have made this task a little easy for you by doing the research for you. Let us look at why we need pacifiers in the first place. Pacifiers are helpful for soothing fussy babies and can be used during naps and bedtime. They can also help with the transition between breast- and bottle-feeding. They offer your child a calming sensation, improve sleeping habits, and comfort them when they are stressed. They come in different shapes, colors, and designs and are textured to prevent them from falling out of your baby’s mouth. If you are wondering which pacifier to pin down in your baby registry, we suggest you browse through our reviews of these tried-and-tested pacifiers suitable for breastfed babies.

In This Article

11 Best Pacifiers For A Breastfed Baby To Calm Down, 2024

1. Best BPA-Free: Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle Giraffe Pacifier

4.7

If you are looking for a lightweight plush toy that doubles up as a pacifier, look no further than the Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle Pacifier. Easy to hold for babies, these colorful and attractive toys by this trusted brand can be used to distract your child from commotions. Made from BPA-free materials, this orthodontic silicone nipple pacifier is flexible and has a soft shield that lets your baby breathe. This pacifier can also be detached from the plush toy to clean in a dishwasher or sterilize in boiling water. The best part about this pacifier is that you can never lose them as long as they are attached to the snuggle giraffe toy. You can check out this review video to learn about this tester’s experience with using the product.

Material: Silicone | Color: Giraffe | Item Weight: ‎3.1 ounces | Product Dimensions: ‎3.23 x 3.23 x 4.72 inches

Pros

  • Cylindrical shape is easier to latch on to
  • Detachable for easy cleaning
  • Made of BPA-free materials
  • Durable and flexible medical-grade silicone
  • Soft and lightweight
  • Can be cleaned, sterilized, or replaced

Cons

  • You may find that the pacifier falls off easily if tugged too hard.

Our Reviewer's Experience

"This pacifier-plushie combo is the most adorable little thing. It’s easy to locate and offers a snug fit while lying down. The holder can fit different types of pacifiers, and the detachable design is a plus for hygiene. Its size seems small, but it works well for my baby."


protip_icon Pro tip
You should allow your baby to use the pacifier only until they’re around 18 months, as prolonged use may cause dental problems (1).

2. Best For Natural Sucking: Medela Soft Silicone Pacifier

4.5
Medela Soft Silicone Pacifier Image: Medela

Medela’s pacifier, trusted by moms, is ergonomically designed to support natural sucking. It features a nipple with an orthodontic shape, with a flat symmetric teat and thin shaft, allowing for flexible tongue movements and reducing the space between the upper and lower jaws. The pacifier also has SensoPearls that maximize airflow, allowing your baby to breathe comfortably. Made of 100% food-grade silicone material to ensure a non-toxic touch. Additionally, it comes with a Steribox, which helps you sterilize it in the microwave or steam-clean it in just three minutes.

Material: Silicone | Color: Pink/Transparent (Soft Silicone) | Item Weight: ‎1.92 ounces | Product Dimensions: ‎2.95 x 1.97 x 6.3 inches

Pros

  • Gentle on the baby’s delicate skin
  • Wide base
  • BPA- and BPS-free
  • One-piece design
  • Soft nipple
  • Cylindrical shape is easier to latch on to

Cons

  • Rims may be too large for small babies
  • May be slightly heavy for newborns

Our Reviewer's Experience

"Its flexible build is very soft, and the BPA-free material keeps me worry-free even when my little one chews on it. It is also easy to clean and does not retain any water. Plus, the case is a boon for storage and sterilization."


3. Best Lightweight: Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Pacifier

4.7

The lightweight and mom-approved Tommee Tippee ultra-light silicone soother comes with a pacifier nipple that supports your baby’s natural oral development. The durable 100% medical-grade silicone is soft and flexible with a skin-like texture that will give your baby a feeling of familiarity. This pacifier also comes with a curved shield designed to comfortably fit between your baby’s nose and chin, along with large holes that facilitate extra airflow. Prevent any moisture buildup that can lead to skin irritations with this hygienic pacifier with anti-static properties against dust settlements. They have a dishwasher-safe one-piece design and are available in three sizes, making them suitable for newborns to 12-month-old babies. If you need further convincing, check this YouTuber’s review out.

Material: Silicone | Color: Light Blue & Light Green | Item Weight: ‎2.08 ounces | Product Dimensions: ‎3.62 x 4.65 x 7.01 inches

Pros

  • Promotes healthy oral development
  • Made from soft and 100% medical-grade silicone
  • Taste-free and does not retain stains or odors
  • Anti-static properties
  • Lightweight and easy to clean
  • Sterilizer-safe

Cons

  • You may find the size to be smaller than you expect.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

It's no wonder that this quality product has earned over 16,473 positive reviews on Amazon.

Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle Giraffe Pacifier
Best BPA-Free
Medela Soft Silicone Pacifier
Best For Natural Sucking
Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Pacifier
Best Lightweight
Material Silicone Silicone Silicone
Color Giraffe Pink/Transparent (Soft Silicone) Light Blue & Light Green
Weight ‎3.1 ounces ‎1.92 ounces ‎2.08 ounces
Dimensions ‎3.23 x 3.23 x 4.72 inches ‎2.95 x 1.97 x 6.3 inches ‎3.62 x 4.65 x 7.01 inches
Rating
Reviews17,95329916,473
Price$14.95$6.99$15.99

4. Best Handmade: Zoe B Organic Simply Rubber Pacifier

3.9
Zoe B Organic Simply Rubber Pacifier Image: Zoë B Organic

The Zoe B Organic rubber pacifier is specially designed for preemies and newborns. It features a short rounded nipple that effectively mimics the real nipple and a shield that features a couple of vents to ensure comfortable breathing for your baby. This pacifier is BPA- and plastic-free and made of rubber milk from the sap of Hevea brasiliensis trees. Further, the pacifier is coated with vegetable oil to prevent damage until use.

Material: Rubber | Item Weight: ‎0.774 ounces

Pros

  • Breast-like pacifier
  • Meticulously handmade by Italian artisans
  • Phthalate- and nitrosamine-free
  • Reduces the risk of gagging
  • Doesn’t leave marks on the infant’s face
  • Heart-shape shield to not restrict the nose

Cons

  • Might have an odor
  • Might be a bit sticky
protip_icon Did you know?
An orthodontic pacifier mimics the shape of a natural nipple and helps properly align the sucking posture, encouraging effective sucking.

5. Best Phthalate Free:Chicco PhysioForma Orthodontic Silicone Pacifier

If you are looking for soft and flexible pacifiers, this clinically-tested and orthodontic silicone pacifier is right for you. Equipped with a contoured shield and four ventilation holes for better air circulation, this high-quality pacifier mimics breastfeeding and helps reduce moisture buildup. These extra-soft nipples help your baby stay latched and actively support their breathing. The pacifier nipple’s unique angle and lateral curve help spread tongue pressure equally around your baby’s palate. The proper positioning of the tongue is driven by tiny ridges and an inclined nipple shape that support your baby’s developing palate and teeth. Since it’s made entirely of food-grade silicone, this one-piece expert-approved pacifier with an easy-to-grab handle is a great choice for both the baby and parent, making it a favorite pacifier of many reviewers.

Material: Silicone | Color: Clear Two Pack | Item Weight: ‎2.46 ounces | Product Dimensions: ‎2.5 x 2 x 1.7 inches

Pros

  • Ensures proper tongue placement
  • Wide base
  • Breast-like pacifier made from soft and flexible high-quality silicone
  • Contoured shield with ventilation holes
  • Extra-soft nipples that support breathing
  • Easy-to-grab handle
  • Comes with a storage-sterilizing case

Cons

  • Pacifiers may become discolored over time.

My Personal Experience

"Their large rings make it easy for my little one to hold them, and the vents prevent moisture accumlation. Its transparent design is prone to staining, but the included sanitizing case has kept that from happening. Overall, it has been the perfect find for my teething infant."


Why We Think It's Worth Buying

This product is a hit with users, evidenced by the 6,802 fine reviews on Amazon.

6. Best Wear-Resistant: Bibs Baby Pacifier

If you are looking for the best round pacifier, the BIBS baby pacifier might be suitable. This mommy-approved pacifier features a cherry-shaped nipple, much like a mother’s breasts for a gentle and familiar sucking experience. The pacifier shape is designed to promote a normal sucking reflex as well as breastfeeding. The nipple has a vent hole that lets air out. Free from BPA, PVC, and phthalates, these natural rubber-based pacifiers are available in three sizes for babies up to 36 months.

Material: Pvc,Iron | Color: Iron/Sand | Item Weight: ‎0.845 ounces

Pros

  • Enables self-soothing
  • 100% free from BPA, PVC, and phthalates
  • Can be sterilized
  • Made of soft and flexible material
  • Cylindrical shape
  • Equipped with a vent hole to let out air
  • Wear-resistant shield made of polypropylene (PP)

Cons

  • Some users found that the nipple stretched out slightly after a few months of use.
Our Reviewer's Experience

"After trying numerous brands, I've found these pacifiers to soothe my baby well. They're lightweight and don’t leave marks on the skin. Although cleaning them takes extra time because of water retention issues, it’s no big deal compared to their convenience."

7. Best Durable: Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Silicone Pacifiers

With these safety-tested and cute pacifiers from Itzy Ritzy, you can help soothe your baby in style. Every pacifier has a design on the handle to match your baby’s outfits and is made of sturdy, latex-free, 100% food-grade silicone. These baby-friendly and BPA-free pacifiers comply with ASTM safety requirements and have two holes for proper ventilation. They are ideal for newborn babies up to their teething period and are available in a pack of two with gray and yellow identical pacifiers. You can conveniently store and carry two pacifiers in the coordinating pacifier pod that comes with this set.

Material: Silicone | Color: Dark Gray & Yellow | Item Weight: ‎0.64 ounces | Product Dimensions: ‎2 x 2 x 2.35 inches

Pros

  • Made of 100% food-grade silicone
  • Equipped with 2 large air holes for breathing
  • Cylindrical shape is easier to latch on to
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Soft and durable
  • Comes with a collapsible handle for added safety

Cons

  • This pacifier may have a slightly rubbery scent.

Our Reviewer's Experience

"Their unique colors were the first thing that attracted me to them. Besides, they have also impressed me with their design and functionality. However, I recommended using a clip to keep them from being tossed around."


8. Best Sterilizer-Safe: Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier

4.6
Dr. Brown's HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier Image: Dr. Brown's
Now 17% Off

Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci pacifier features a contoured butterfly-shaped shield that provides enough room for your little one to breathe comfortably while facilitating ample space for the cheeks. The one-piece body makes it suitable for infants aged zero to six months, and the silicone construction makes the pacifier soft and lightweight. Additionally, the pacifier shape is similar to that of Dr. Brown’s bottle nipple, making it easy for infants to seamlessly transition between the bottle and the pacifier. They are available in blue, pink, grey and multiple other colors.

Material: Silicone | Color: 3-Pack, Variety Pack (Black, White, Gray) | Item Weight: ‎6.4 ounces

Pros

  • Dishwasher- and sterilizer-safe
  • Free of BPA
  • Easy to hold
  • Cylindrical shape is easier to latch on to
  • Three-in-one pack for convenience

Cons

  • May not be suitable for teething
  • Nipple may be longer than expected

Our Reviewer's Experience

"With this option, I have finally found a pacifier that comforts my little one while also being easy to manage. These are substantial enough to sustain my little one’s chewing, and the colors look pleasing. My baby uses similar bottle nipples, so she has quickly adjusted to these."


Why We Think It's Worth Buying

The product boasts 2,390 reviews on Amazon, and many buyers have said they would purchase the product again.

9. Best Ergonomic Design: Nanobebe Flexy Baby Pacifier

If you want to discourage nipple confusion as you soothe and calm your newborn baby, this Nanobebe Flexy Pacifier will do the job. The extra-soft silicone is made of healthy BPA-free and phthalate-free silicone and keeps your baby’s comfort in mind. The pacifier’s lightweight and ergonomic design makes it baby-friendly and easy for little ones to hold. Nanobebe’s gentle and calming silicone baby pacifiers will soothe your baby’s cries, no matter what time of day. Teach your baby to self-soothe between feedings, in the car, and before bedtime using these pacifiers. Each silicone teething pacifier encourages good oral hygiene and is soft on your baby’s gums and teeth.

Material: Silicone | Color: Teal | Item Weight: ‎1.65 ounces | Product Dimensions: ‎5.91 x 3.94 x 1.57 inches

Pros

  • Extra-soft nipple for comfort
  • Lightweight and ergonomic design
  • Made of silicone
  • BPA and phthalate-free

Cons

  • Some may find this pacifier to be rather small-sized.

Our Reviewer's Experience

"Besides soothing my baby, its ergonomic shape has helped correct her latch. Despite the lightweight design, it stays put and has remained stain-free even after being used regularly."


protip_icon Quick fact
This pacifier is sterilizer- and dishwasher-safe. It is designed and crafted per AAP safety guidelines to meet the standards.

10. Best Latex-Free: The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifiers

An innovatively designed one-piece construction with durable, latex-free silicone is brought to you by The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifiers. Available in bright colors, these newborn baby pacifiers fit the baby’s face allowing them to breathe easily. This pacifier is compatible with most attachers and is light enough for your baby to carry. Available in various bright and appealing colors, they have a distinctive contoured form that helps your baby to self-soothe with ease.

Material: Silicone | Color: Blue/Green | Item Weight: ‎0.64 ounces | Product Dimensions: ‎0.71 x 5.75 x 3.86 inches

Pros

  • Unique contoured shape
  • Latex-free silicone pacifier
  • Lightweight and easy to handle
  • Cylindrical shape is easier to latch on to
  • Available in multiple colors
  • Suitable for 0-3 months

Cons

  • This pacifier is not dishwasher-safe.

11. Best Phthalate Free:Ryan And Rose Cutie Pacifier And Teether

This pacifier and teether combo from Ryan and Rose is ideal for babies without teeth. Made of ultra-soft, BPA-free, medical-grade silicone, this safe and effective product does not contain PVC, phthalates, or latex. This pacifier acts as a teething toy for growing infants, making it a safe, soothing option for your baby. When needed, you can easily connect it to a pacifier clip, and the nipple can be easily tucked away when used as a teether. This pacifier’s soft nipple provides a breastfeeding-like experience for natural palate growth, while the soother is gentle on the baby’s gums. It has a one-piece body for easy cleaning and prevention of dirt accumulation. You can also match these pacifiers to your baby’s outfits, thanks to the neutral colors.

Material: Silicone | Color: Black | Item Weight: ‎0.634 ounces

Pros

  • Round and soft nipple
  • Seamless one-piece design
  • Large round-shaped shield for chewing surface
  • Breathing holes for enhanced airflow
  • Equipped with a solid handle for easy grip
  • Dishwasher-safe

Cons

  • You may find the nipple to be too small.
*The prices provided in this article are based on the latest available information. However, they may vary due to changes in pricing by the seller and/or promotional offers.

How To Choose The Right Pacifier For A Breastfed Baby?

Keep the following points in mind when choosing a pacifier for your baby.

  1. Child’s age: You can avoid giving a pacifier to your breastfed baby until they are around three to four weeks old. You just want to make sure they’ve somewhat mastered the feeding process before moving on to another option and method of calming them. Self-soothing can take time to get accustomed to and pacifiers play a role in helping both mother and baby. Pacifiers best suit children between the ages of 0-36 months. You may want to weigh in on a few different options during this period.
  1. Colors and shapes: Asymmetrical pacifiers with an orthodontic design approved by dentists make it easier for babies to hold it in their mouths and support normal oral growth. You may want to use a straight nipple pacifier instead of a curved one, but that depends on what your baby prefers too. Choose a single-piece, dishwasher-safe choice, so that you are not hassled when you find yourself constantly cleaning up. Avoid pacifiers that are made of two parts as they can split and can cause choking. The best pacifiers are bright colored and attractive. They also come with glow-in-the-dark features, so that you can find them more easily at night.
  1. Material and size: When it comes to pacifiers, the most important factors to remember are the material and size. Latex or silicone are the most common materials used in pacifiers, and both choices are appropriate. You will want to keep in mind that latex allergies are a common occurrence, so you can opt for a silicone pacifier if you need to. You should also be sure that your pacifier is BPA-free and free from PVC and phthalates. Healthy composition materials go a long way in keeping your baby safe when they use these soothing pacifiers.

Regina Kincaid, a midwife and lactation consultant and the reviewer of this article, says, Choose round or cylindrical pacifiers as they are comforting for the baby since they imitate the form of a woman’s nipple. Also, ensure you get the right size for your baby’s age and replace it if damaged.”

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What are the risks of giving a baby a pacifier?

Giving your baby a pacifier poses no such significant risks, but it may cause nipple confusion, promote habit formation and dependency, and affect tooth development if not used carefully. It can also take some time for you or your child to get used to it. Parents concerned about how a pacifier can affect their child’s dental development can rest assured that there will be no problems unless the pacifier is used for an extended period. You must also ensure that the pacifier is sterilized regularly, as the pacifier will expose your baby to illness.

2. Do I need to get a BPA-free pacifier?

Yes, while looking for a pacifier, ensure that they are BPA-free. You can also opt for BPA-free medical grade silicone nipples over latex ones as they may cause some allergies for sensitive babies.

3. Should I get a rounded nipple or orthodontic nipple pacifier?

Rounded nipple pacifiers are long and slim, with a rounded tip on top that resembles a human nipple. Orthodontic-shaped pacifiers are more oval-shaped, with one flat side, to make it easier for your baby to suck and avoid future tooth problems. For breastfed infants, the rounded nipple shape is more similar to a mother’s nipple and could be a safer choice. The round type should be tried first, followed by the orthodontic design.

4. When should I replace a pacifier?

When you see a hole, discolored parts, or a stretched nipple, it’s time to change your baby’s pacifier. You can also replace the item if the plastic on the guard or handle has become jagged or if the pacifier is loose in some sections to avoid the pacifier breaking in.

5. Are pacifiers bad for a baby’s teeth?

Dentists discovered that pacifiers could cause some babies’ mouths to grow incorrectly, potentially leading to premature tooth growth in the future. The most primary issue that you will likely face is misaligned or crooked teeth or bite issues. Successfully weaning your child off the pacifier until they turn two will help you avoid these problems.

Why Trust MomJunction?

A pacifier can help calm your grumpy baby, especially during their naptime, to improve their sleeping habits. However, with a multitude of options available, you might be confused about choosing the right one for your baby. Therefore, Vibha Navarathna, our in-house writer and reviewer of baby products, has compiled this list of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies. She has gone through various user comments about the products and brands on different platforms. Vibha has also added a buying guide and answered a few common questions about pacifiers that would help you choose the right pacifier for your baby.

The Bottom Line

Pacifiers are essential for parents to calm a fussy baby, especially during naptime. The best pacifiers for breastfed babies are also ideal for your little one’s teeth and jaw development and help babies get better, calmer sleep at night. Besides, it helps them to seamlessly transition from breast- to bottle-feeding. When choosing a pacifier, ensure it is made of soft, lightweight, flexible, and food-grade material and is easy to clean. Our top picks include the BPA-free Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle Giraffe Pacifier, the Medela Soft Silicone Pacifier with a flexible nipple, and the Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Pacifier made of 100% medical-grade silicone. Further, pacifiers should be brightly colored and be easy to handle to engage your baby and help them self-soothe.


References

MomJunction's articles are written after analyzing the research works of expert authors and institutions. Our references consist of resources established by authorities in their respective fields. You can learn more about the authenticity of the information we present in our editorial policy.
  1. Pacifiers: When to Stop Using Them
    https://www.nationwidechildrens.org/family-resources-education/700childrens/2022/12/pacifiers

Recommended Articles:

Was this article helpful?
thumbsupthumbsdown
The following two tabs change content below.