13 Best Sandwich Makers In 2024, Expert-Approved

If you or your children love sandwiches, you will need the best sandwich makers. A sandwich maker is a device you can use to make sandwiches by stacking up layers of meat, eggs, cheese, or vegetables. They help in toasting your sandwiches until they achieve the required brown look.

Also, if you have a suitable device, you can make the best sandwiches without bread for a perfect paleolithic diet. Read on as we list the best sandwich makers recommended by home experts and tell you what you should consider when choosing the right sandwich maker.

In This Article

13 Best Sandwich Makers To Buy In 2024

1. Best Customizable: Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.5
Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker with Timer, Silver (25490A) Image: Image: Hamilton Beach
worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

Join the 21,041 satisfied buyers on Amazon who have said the product meets their needs and expectations.

This quality-tested sandwich maker is a great option for making two customized sandwiches at a time. The dual-sided sandwich maker cooks sandwiches within five minutes and comes with a plate for cooking and layering an egg within the bun. It even has a digital timer with a beep alert to maintain the correct cooking time. You may check more about this easy-to-use toastie maker from this review video.

Wattage: 1200 watts | Product Dimensions: 8"D x 10.5"W x 6"H | Material: Plastic | Color: Silver | Item Weight: 4.8 pounds

Pros

  • Non-stick coating makes it easy to clean
  • Removable parts are dishwasher-safe
  • Egg plate slides out after cooking
  • Handy recipe guide included

Cons

  • Eggs may leak out of the plate
  • Plate may not cook eggs properly

My Personal Experience

"My mornings have been transformed by this sandwich maker, which helps me create compact and spill-free sandwiches and mini-burgers. Its ability to make two portions simultaneously saves me time. I would have loved it more if it came with an auto-shutoff feature."


protip_icon Trivia
John Montagu, the 4th Earl of Sandwich, didn’t want to leave the card table to eat and asked for his meat to be served between two bread slices; that’s how the sandwich came into existence.

2. Cuisinart WM-SW2N Dual-Sandwich Non-Stick Electric Grill

Cuisinart WM-SW2N Dual-Sandwich non-stick Electric Grill

This grilled sandwich maker is a good choice if you want to cook gourmet food on functional grills. It can fit up to two sandwiches that can be diagonally cut when cooking and comes with a three-year warranty. This review video gives you more information about the product.

Pros

  • Durable grill plates
  • Non-stick surfaces for easy cleaning
  • Cooks omelets, waffles, and French toast
  • Locking lid ensures both sides are browned evenly
  • Dual indicator lights

Cons

  • Heat may not be adequate for cooking sandwiches
  • Cooking area is not very deep

Our Tester's Experience

"Thanks to its nonstick plates, I no longer have to soak my preparations in oil. Plus, the lockable lid mechanism helps me yield cafe-like sandwiches every morning."


3. Best Durable Grill Plates:Dash DMG001SL Mini Maker Portable Grill Machine

This tried-and-tested product is one of the best sandwich makers if you have a kitchenette. It allows you to customize your sandwiches and has an easy-to-lift handle for a comfortable cooking experience. The versatile and portable sandwich maker can also be used for grilling fruit, meats, and vegetables and making great food for breakfast.

Wattage: 350 watts | Item Weight: 1 Pounds | Material: Nonstick | Color: Silver | Product Dimensions: 5"D x 2.8"W x 6"H

Pros

  • Durable and lightweight sandwich grill
  • Quickly reaches optimum temperature
  • PFOA-free, non-stick cooking surface for easy cleaning
  • Large preheating and cooking indicators
  • Non-slip feet make it sturdy

Cons

  • May generate a lot of smoke
  • No switch to turn it on/off
  • Sandwiches have to be flipped

Our Reviewer's Experience

"I can now grill almost anything to perfection with this press. It renders my filets and patties toasty and distinctive grill lines, adding a gourmet charm to my food and making it more tasty. I also found that it heats the food pieces evenly."


worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

About 11,365 reviewers on Amazon have given their seal of approval to the product.

Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker
Cuisinart WM-SW2N Dual-Sandwich Non-Stick Electric Grill
Dash DMG001SL Mini Maker Portable Grill Machine
Wattage 1200 watts- 350 watts
Dimensions 8"D x 10.5"W x 6"H- 5"D x 2.8"W x 6"H
Material Plastic- Nonstick
Color Silver- Silver
Weight 4.8 pounds- 1 Pounds
Rating
Reviews21,041-11,365
Price$46.99$44.96$12.99
Buy NowBuy NowBuy Now

4. Best For Grilling Meat:T-fal EZ Clean Sandwich And Waffle Maker

This multifunctional sandwich maker has two sets of cooking plates that can be switched to make waffles or sandwiches. The quality-tested electric sandwich maker is a great option for making breakfast for your family.

Item Weight: 5.66 Pounds | Wattage: 750 watts | Product Dimensions: 9.25"D x 9.65"W x 3.54"H | Material: Stainless Steel | Color: Silver & Black

Pros

  • Fits up to two sandwiches/waffles
  • non-stick plates are dishwasher-safe
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Indicator lights for cooking/heating
  • Can be stored vertically

Cons

  • Handle may break easily
  • Manual provided may not be useful

5. Best Indicator Lights:Yoshikawa SJ2408 Hot Sandwich Maker

This is one of the best toasted sandwich makers for use on a stovetop. Made of durable aluminum alloy, this sandwich maker is a good option if you want to toast a sandwich on an open fire outdoors or a gas stove. This sandwich maker offers a convenient way to cook your favorite snacks quickly.

Wattage: 1000 watts | Material: Body: Aluminum alloy (0.07 inch (1.8 mm)); Fluorine resin processing; Handle: Phenolic resin | Color: Black | Item Weight: 13.4 ounces | Product Dimensions: 15.16 x 6.18 x 1.38 inches

Pros

  • Non-stick coated interior
  • Durable heat-resistant handle
  • Requires less oil when cooking

Cons

  • Material of the pan is thin
My Personal Experience

"Its handle lock keeps it from opening even when stored upright, and the double baking sides cook my sandwiches in just a few minutes. Occasional filling spills make it a little messy, but the non-stick layer makes cleaning up a breeze."

6. Best Heat-Resistant Handle:Gotham Steel 2108 Maker

worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

More than 10,434 independent reviewers on Amazon have acknowledged the product's durability and functionality.

This is a stylish pocket sandwich maker. The compact sandwich maker fits two pieces at a time and makes perfectly cut and cooked sandwiches with ease. As per the reviewers, the sandwich sealer reaches an optimum cooking temperature quickly and creates perfect sandwich pockets within minutes.

Item Weight: 0.01 Ounces | Wattage: 1400 watts | Product Dimensions: 6"D x 12"W x 6"H | Material: Copper | Color: Black

Pros

  • Easy-to-clean non-stick surface
  • Ceramic- and titanium-reinforced surface releases food quickly
  • No need for oil or butter
  • Heat-resistant handle
  • Offers diagonal indentation
  • Compact and durable build
  • Indicator lights let you know when the sandwiches are cooked

Cons

  • Does not fit in thick sandwiches
  • Does not close properly
  • Handle tends to break

Our Reviewer's Experience

"It offers consistent results regardless of the fillings and bread I use. Cleaning it is a bit cumbersome if the cheese spills, but it grills the sandwiches evenly. Overall, it has been quite the kitchen ally for making quick sandwiches for breakfast and dinner."


protip_icon Did you know?
Preheating the sandwich maker helps prevent the sandwich from sticking to the cooking plates, as the heat will help to create a non-stick surface.

7. Best Compact:IMUSA USA GAU-80103 Electric Stainless Steel Panini Maker

This device is one of the best toasted sandwich makers as it comes with a floating hinge that allows you to adjust the cooking height. The compact sandwich maker is a good choice to cook gourmet food and paninis and toast or grill vegetables and meat.

Wattage: 1400 watts | Material: Stainless Steel | Color: Silver | Item Weight: 5.65 pounds | Product Dimensions: 10.5 x 11.7 x 4 inches

Pros

  • Grills sandwiches, vegetables, and meats
  • Non-stick surface can be easily cleaned with a cloth
  • Durable build with steel exterior
  • Power and heat indicator lights
  • Sturdy and safe design

Cons

  • Difficult to close
  • Hinge may not be durable
Our Reviewer's Experience

"Preparing restaurant-style submarine sandwiches at home is now a hassle-free task for me. The device also allows me to sear steaks and vegetables without tossing and turning them every few minutes."

8. Best Non-Stick Surface:Proctor Silex Sandwich Maker

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.4

This tried-and-tested sandwich maker is a must-have kitchen item that features non-stick cooking plates. The compact-sized non-stick sandwich press with a sturdy design is easy to use and creates perfectly cooked grilled cheese sandwiches within minutes.

Wattage: 900 watts | Material: Nonstick | Color: White | Item Weight: 3.13 pounds | Product Dimensions: 9.5 x 9.9 x 4 inches

Pros

  • Non-stick coated surface can be easily cleaned
  • Preheating and power-on indicator lights
  • Can be stored upright
  • Cord can be easily wrapped
  • Efficient locking system

Cons

  • No grill lines
  • Uneven heating

Our Reviewer's Experience

"Its dual-sided heating plates allow me to enjoy crunchy toasts in a matter of minutes. Although it accommodates bread slices only within a particular size range, its professional-grade heating system outweighs the minor limitation. Also, I find it easy to store and clean."


9. Best Compact:Chefman Electric Panini Press Grill And Gourmet Sandwich Maker

This is the best grilled sandwich maker that can also work as a panini press. It is designed to fit two sandwiches with a lot of filling. The compact sandwich press can also be opened flat, and you can use each grill side individually. It can also be used to make a multilayer sandwich.

Item Weight: 4 Pounds | Wattage: 1000 watts | Product Dimensions: 10"D x 12"W x 5"H | Material: Stainless Steel | Color: Black

Pros

  • 180-degree open-flat cooking position
  • Floating hingedesign
  • Bottom and top grill plates can be operated individually
  • Skid-resistant feet and compact size
  • Removable drip tray
  • Non-stick plates can be quickly cleaned

Cons

  • Does not fit two sandwiches comfortably
  • Closes at an angle and is difficult to use

Our Reviewer's Experience

"It heats quickly and cooks my sandwiches evenly. Its compact size also makes storage hassle-free. I wish its plates were detachable, but the wide opening design still makes cleaning manageable. So, I plan on sticking to it."


protip_icon Remember
Put the appliance on a heat-resistant surface, as it generates heat during cooking that may scorch or damage the surface.

10. Best With Run-Off Channels:Black+Decker 3-In-1 Sandwich Maker

This electric sandwich maker is a versatile offering and has removable plates that can be used as an indoor grill to cook meat/vegetables or make waffles and sandwiches. As per reviews, this breakfast sandwich maker has a durable build and elegant design to suit most modern kitchens.

Wattage: 1800 watts | Material: Stainless Steel | Color: Black/Silver | Item Weight: 6.2 pounds | Product Dimensions: 9 x 9 x 4 inches

Pros

  • Grill, sandwich, and waffle plates
  • Preheating and power indicators
  • Heat-resistant handles
  • Non-stick plates are dishwasher-safe
  • Run-off channels for removing grease
  • Cool-touch handles

Cons

  • Non-stick coating is not durable
  • Temperature cannot be controlled
Our Reviewer's Experience

"The best part about this appliance is its versatility. It can make everything from a sandwich, grilled wrap, or waffles. Its removable heating places also allow me to thoroughly clean the smells and stains. It takes some time to cool, but the handle makes storage easy."

11. Best Easy-To-Carry:Brentwood Panini Press And Sandwich Maker

This sandwich maker cum panini press is a great option if you want to cook healthy meals with whole grain bread. The sandwich press has a good-sized cooking area and can fit up to two sandwiches and toast them fast.

Wattage: 750 watts | Product Dimensions: 9.6"D x 10.1"W x 4.3"H | Material: Stainless Steel | Color: Black | Item Weight: 2.5 pounds | Product Dimensions: 10.1 x 9.6 x 4.3 inches

Pros

  • Power and preheating indicators
  • Secure lock on the handle
  • Easy storage and portability
  • Non-stick plates can be easily cleaned

Cons

  • Handle and exterior may not be durable
  • Non-stick coating peels off
Our Reviewer's Experience

"This handy device allows me to fix cafe-like sandwiches at home. Its non-stick coating is a boon for cleaning, and its petite structure does not take up too much counter space. Its heating could have been more efficient, but it still toasts the bread well."

12. Best For Two Sandwiches:OSTBA Sandwich Maker

This is a good-quality pocket sandwich maker. The versatile sandwich toaster can also be used to make panini sandwiches and allows you to make nutritious breakfasts and snacks for your family.

Wattage: 750 watts | Color: Black | Item Weight: 2.42 pounds | Product Dimensions: 8.66 x 3.15 x 8.27 inches

Pros

  • Superior non-stick coating on plates
  • Easy to clean with a damp cloth
  • Fits two sandwiches easily
  • Two indicator lights
  • Cable can be easily wrapped and stored
  • Safety lock allows for easy closure
  • Cool-touch handle
  • Double-side baking

Cons

  • Does not close properly
  • Exterior parts may crack/break quickly
Our Reviewer's Experience

"It has proven a dependable device for making triangle sandwiches and panini toasts. Its red and green indicator lights are also pretty helpful to prevent overheating. Its base could have been more stable, but placing it on dry surfaces has kept slips at bay."

13. Best Lightweight:Ovente Electric Sandwich Maker

*The prices provided in this article are based on the latest available information. However, they may vary due to changes in pricing by the seller and/or promotional offers.

This quality-tested elegant and quick sandwich maker can be easily operated and has a versatile design, allowing you to cook omelets, pocket sandwiches, and French toast. The sandwich toaster heats up quickly and gets breakfast cooked faster.

Item Weight: 2.4 Pounds | Wattage: 750 watts | Product Dimensions: 9"D x 9"W x 3.5"H | Material: Non-Stick Coating | Color: Black Sandwich Maker

Pros

  • Heats up within three minutes
  • Anti-skid feet prevent any slipping
  • Durable and heat-resistant body and handle
  • Non-stick coated and deep-pocketed plates
  • Lightweight device can be easily transported
  • Power and preheating indicator lights

Cons

  • Produces a foul smell as it heats up
  • Non-stick coating may peel off
Our Tester's Experience

"Making tea sandwiches and toasts had never been this easy and satisfying. This device has been both a time and space saver. The lack of an on/off switch is a letdown, but the red and green lights always save my sandwiches from getting burnt."

How To Choose The Right Sandwich Maker?

To know how people go about choosing the right sandwich maker for their needs, continue reading. 

  1. Consider your family size: If you have a family of four to six members and need to make snacks or breakfast every day, buy a sandwich maker that can hold a minimum of two sandwiches. This will allow you to make breakfast at a faster pace.
  2. Versatility of the device:Buy a sandwich maker that has removable plates for making waffles or grilling vegetables. This allows you to get the most out of it when making breakfast or a snack.
  3. Electric or stovetop: Based on whether you want to cook without increasing your electricity bill or just want to go camping, choose an electric or stovetop sandwich maker. A stovetop sandwich maker comes in handy when cooking outdoors.
  4. Durability and compactness: Getting a compact sandwich maker allows for storage in an upright position, which is perfect for a small kitchen or a college dorm room.
  5. Coating on the cooking surfaces: A sandwich maker that has a Teflon or non-stick coating on the cooking surface or plates can be easily cleaned with a damp cloth and kept free of rust and corrosion.
  6. Thermal insulation and floating hinges: Sandwich makers with good thermal insulation can be operated easily as the handles and body remain cool to touch and do not cause burns. Floating hinges allow for sandwiches with more fillings to be toasted easily, while locks allow the lid to remain secure.
  7.  Additional features to consider: The best sandwich makers come with several nifty features, including space for wrapping the cable, power indicators, and an on/off switch. So, consider these additional features.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the difference between a sandwich maker and a panini maker?

Sandwich and panini makers toast and grill bread and sandwiches. The only difference is that the panini maker is specially designed for panini-shaped bread but can also be used for sandwich bread. On the other hand, a sandwich maker cannot be interchangeably used for panini bread due to its four triangular-pocket designs.

2. What is the difference between a sandwich maker and a griller?

Here are the common differences between the two appliances: (a) A sandwich maker is an electrical device; a griller can be electrical or stove-top-based. (b) A sandwich maker has exclusive triangular pockets; a griller has a BBQ-style flat plate. (c) A sandwich maker cannot grill other foods; a griller can toast sandwiches. (d) A sandwich maker cannot separate grease from food, but a griller can.

3. Are sandwich makers useful?

Sandwich makers are compact, cost-effective electrical devices that instantly prepare well-toasted crispy triangular sandwiches. They have user-friendly designs and are easy to maintain. Grillers, however, are heavy-duty and don’t bestow your sandwiches the classic triangular shape.

4. What else can I do with a sandwich maker?

The triangular plates sandwich maker can churn out omelets and french toast, while the ring-styled maker can help make taco cups, mini pizzas, mini burgers, molten lava cake, etc. The griller ones can cook almost any BBQ-based meal.

Why Trust MomJunction?

Our household and kitchen appliance reviewer, Sakshi John, prioritizes quality products that are highly safe, easy to use, and have a portable design. This list of top sandwich makers available in the market was compiled after extensively researching multiple online forums and user reviews. Furthermore, these sandwich makers have various features, such as an in-built waffle maker, to help you pick one according to your requirements.

The Bottom Line

So, if you are craving a delicious sandwich, a sandwich maker can come to your rescue. When purchasing one, look for features like ease of use, lightweight build, and easy maintenance. You might also want to check the sandwich makers, like the Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker, which can make multiple sandwiches simultaneously for enhanced convenience. Additional features, such as adjustable heat, waffle making, and vegetable grilling options, as seen in the Dash DMG001SL Mini Maker Portable Grill Machine, can elevate your snacking experience. You could also look for non-stick devices like the Gotham Steel 2108 Maker. We hope our list of the best sandwich makers can help you analyze the available options to find a suitable one.

Infographic: How To Clean A Sandwich Maker?

Besides procuring a high-quality sandwich maker, it is also essential to use it properly to increase its durability and ensure a mess-free experience. So, check out the following infographic to learn the nitty-gritty involved in keeping the maker spick-and-span.

Tips To Follow To Keep A Sandwich Maker Clean (infographic)

Illustration: Momjunction Design Team


Recommended Articles

Was this article helpful?
Like buttonDislike button
The following two tabs change content below.
Beverly Ramitan wears multiple hats as a licensed electronics and communications engineer, graphics designer, video editor, content creator, and social media manager. She prides in being a hands-on mom to her daughters and following her passion for cooking.
Read full bio of Beverly Ramitan