Image: MomJunction Design Team
If there’s one thing that is representative of every camping trip that involves a bonfire, it is lip-smacking s’mores. But you don’t have to limit the joy of this chocolate and marshmallow dessert to trips that happen once in a while. The best s’mores makers let you make them anytime you want.
These devices come with unique features, and while some are microwave-compatible, others work on canned fuel or electricity. You don’t have to light a bonfire every time you have a craving for s’mores. The portable and easy-to-use options on this list will help you choose the right s’mores maker for your home and turn your backyard into a camping ground.
Sarah Blair, a culinary wellness expert and coach and founder of Pure Palate, says, “The best thing about S’mores kits is that you can choose your ingredients and make any variation. You really can’t go wrong. For a campfire night or an indoor slumber party, select an array of diverse flavored chocolate bars or add options such as nut butter, candied bacon, artisanal potato chips, jams or raw berries, toasted coconut, and even some other cookie options.”
So, check out reviews of some tried-and-tested s’mores makers below. We also give you a few tips on choosing the right s’mores maker.
Top Picks
12 Best S’mores Makers To Buy For Your Home And A 2024 Buying Guide
1. Best Flameless Heater: Nostalgia SMM200 Indoor Electric Stainless Steel S’mores Maker
Image: Nostalgia 
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
With over 13,207 reviews on Amazon, this product is a winner.
With Nostalgia’s electric indoor s’mores maker, preparing s’mores can be real fun and hassle-free. Made of stainless steel, the tabletop flameless electric heater comes with two roasting forks to ensure you get the perfectly roasted golden brown marshmallows for the s’mores. This s’mores maker with built-in compartments is designed for effortless cleaning. Just plug in the power cord to an electric outlet, wait for a few minutes for the coil to heat up, and the s’mores maker is ready for use.
Pros
- BPA-free
- Four-compartment trays
- Durable stainless steel base
- Flameless electric heater
- Safe and user-friendly
Cons
- May take longer to roast marshmallows
- May need to hold the marshmallow a little closer for the perfect roast
"This product has been perfect for making s'mores during rainy days or game nights. I wish it included more roasting sticks for large get-togethers, but the wooden skewers have been the ideal addition to the set. All in all, my family and I find it pretty amazing."
Quick tip2. Best Speed: Progressive Prep Solutions PS-68BR Microwave S’mores Maker
With Progressive Prep Solutions PS-68BR Microwave S’mores Maker, you can make not one, but two s’mores in 30 seconds or less. To use this innovative s’mores maker, place the Graham crackers, chocolate bars, and marshmallows on the tray, fill the water reservoir with water, and microwave it. With this s’mores machine, the chocolate and marshmallows get evenly heated to make the perfect s’mores. This expert-recommended s’mores maker may be an ideal choice for individuals pressed for time.
Pros
- Simple and user-friendly
- Comes with a water reservoir
- Functional tray design with side handles
- Dishwasher- and microwave-safe
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Arms may be flimsy
- Marshmallow may stick to the surface
"Initially, I was doubtful about this s'mores maker, but it has been a hit, especially for my children, who get fussy with traditional roasting. The crisping effect may take some time, but the maker is a neat and efficient way of roasting marshmallows all year round."
3. Best For Outdoors And Indoors: Sterno 70228 Family Fun S’mores Maker
Image: Sterno Why We Think It's Worth Buying
Over 444 satisfied customers have left positive reviews about the product on Amazon.
Ideal for indoor and outdoor use, the Sterno 70228 Family Fun S’ mores Maker can be quite fun to use. The s’ mores maker comes with two stainless steel roasting forks to cook the marshmallows. The tried-and-tested product also contains a roasting screen that protects the food from the flame and helps in uniform toasting, making it one of the favorite s’mores makers among moms and dads. The inclusion of the proprietary Sterno S’ mores Heat Fuel can for roasting the marshmallows is an added advantage.
Pros
- Two built-in stations for making s’mores
- Roasting screen
- Compartments for storing ingredients
- Easy to use and clean
- Suitable for both indoor and outdoor spaces
Cons
- May not be suitable for roasting two or more marshmallows
- Not compatible with any sternos
"It's super easy to assemble this petite fire pit/ marshmallow roaster. Although extinguishing the flame can be tricky, it can be quickly smothered with a kitchen pan. Despite the slight inconvenience, I've enjoyed using it multiple times, and it was a hit at my daughter's birthday party!"
Nostalgia SMM200 Indoor Electric Stainless Steel S'mores Maker Best Flameless Heater | Progressive Prep Solutions PS-68BR Microwave S'mores Maker Best Speed | Sterno 70228 Family Fun S'mores Maker Best For Outdoors And Indoors | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weight | 2 Pounds | 8 ounces | 1.6 pounds |
| Wattage | 270 watts | - | - |
| Dimensions | 12"D x 12"W x 4.7"H | 7.5"W x 4"H | 14 x 14 x 5 inches |
| Material | Stainless Steel | Plastic | - |
| Color | Brown | Brown/White | - |
| Shape | - | Prep | - |
| Rating | |||
| Reviews | 13,207 | 686 | 444 |
| Price | $28.8 | $12.66 | $26.55 |
| Buy Now | Buy Now | Buy Now |
4. Best For Large Batches: Cuisinart S’more to Love STL-611 Six-S’more Maker
As the name suggests, this s’mores maker can make six s’mores at a time. Stack the Graham crackers, chocolate layer, and marshmallow into the compartments of the s’mores maker, lock it and place it over a toaster oven or barbeque grill, and tasty s’mores are ready within minutes. The space between each compartment helps create a convection current when placed over a grill or an oven, ensuring uniform heating of all the six s’mores.
Pros
- Can be used over an oven or a grill
- Easy cleaning with dish soap and a non-abrasive sponge
- Can make six s’mores at a time
- Creates less mess
- Dishwasher-safe
Cons
- Does not reel in or reel out the stick
"This s'mores maker has been a hit at cookouts as it serves over six s'mores at a time with ease. There's a bit of a learning curve with the oven timings and usage, but once accustomed, it delivered great s'mores. I'm looking forward to using it for my next backyard party."
5. Best Set Overall: Hershey’s S’mores Maker Complete Set
If you love campfires and s’mores, then this time-tested s’mores maker by Hershey’s is just for you. The product, consisting of a fuel holder, s’mores maker, four roasting forks, four plates, flame snuffer, and a steel grill, will give you a taste of campfire roasted marshmallows. To ignite the flame for roasting the marshmallows, the base of the ceramic s’mores maker holds a can (standard) of chafing fuel.
Pros
- Complete set from grill to plates
- Easy to assemble
- Recommended hand wash only
- Dimension of the s’mores maker is 6.5″ x 5″
Cons
- May not be suitable for roasting three or more marshmallows at a time
- Body may become hot
Do remember6. Best Convenient: Brentwood TS603 S’mores Maker
Image: Brentwood Why We Think It's Worth Buying
Do not miss out on this product that has earned 515 positive reviews on Amazon.
You can safely toast marshmallows indoors with the Brentwood S’mores maker. This unique s’mores maker with a flameless heater is designed to ensure safe usage. The electric appliance includes a burner lid, four stackable trays, four stainless steel roasting forks, and a user guide. Additionally, the appliance comes with a knob to adjust the coil’s temperature and a power indicator.
Pros
- No open flame
- Offer even heat distribution
- Stainless steel base for easy cleaning
- Provides plastic handles for the fork to prevent scald
- Light indicator
Cons
- May not be suitable for roasting multiple marshmallows
- Warming may take long
"I purchased this for my nieces and nephews, and their delight was palpable. Its compact size has made it convenient for use when they have friends over during birthdays or sleepovers. It does require some practice to get the roasting just right, but all in all, it's been a functional addition."
7. Best Durable: Casa Moda”S’mores” Maker
The Casa Moda”S’mores” Maker can be used both indoors and outdoors. The product comes with a marshmallow-roasting grill, removable ingredient tray made of ceramic, four roasting forks, and a stainless steel lazy Susan base to hold the ceramic ingredient holders and the grill. This s’mores maker with a roasting grill typically runs on chafing fuel (2-6oz can), which should be purchased separately.
Pros
- Grill comprises a burner for the fuel
- Includes a handle and snuffer to put off the flame
- Dimension of the marshmallow roasting grill is 5-¼” by 5-½”
- Should be hand-washed to avoid damage of any parts
- Versatile and modern design
Cons
- Bottom may be prone to scratches
- Metal lid may have slightly sharp edges
"This chair exceeded my expectations for an oversized fishing and camping chair. It's durable enough to sustain the roughhousing of my dogs, and the side pockets and air vents have come in handy when outdoors. Despite a minor concern about the depth, I've found this chair to be a good fit for me."
8. Best Safe-To-Use: Salton SP1717 S’mores & Fondue Maker
Salton SP1717 S’mores & Fondue Maker is an “open flame” s’mores maker that runs on electricity. This s’mores maker with two adjustable heat settings: one for s’mores and the other one for fondue, is a user-friendly product. The expert-recommended s’mores maker comprises a stainless steel housing, four marshmallow roasting forks/ skewers, and detachable plastic trays.
Pros
- No open flame; hence safe to use
- Roasts marshmallows in about two minutes
- Fondue remains at the perfect temperature and consistency
- Compartments for easy organization of ingredients
Cons
- Lid over the coil may be flimsy
- Heating element may be weak
9. Best Portable: Chicago Metallic S’mores Maker
A small and portable product, Chicago Metallic S’mores maker comprises an ensemble of grill top, roasting chimney, four marshmallow roasting forks, a four-compartment serving tray, a snuffer, and a burner holder. The roasting chimney and serving tray are made of high-quality white ceramic. The ceramic components should be allowed to cool down completely before you clean or wash them. For a safe and hassle-free experience, make sure you read the user manual properly before testing and using the product.
Pros
- Stay-cool handles of the fork for easy grip
- Fuel-holder and grill-top are made of superior-quality durable stainless steel
- Ceramic tray and other parts are dishwasher-friendlyrts are dishwasher friendly
- Easy to use
Cons
- Doesn’t come with chafing fuel
- Grill may discolor after regular use
"I've relished using this s'mores maker in both indoor and outdoor settings. It exudes style with its chic ceramic make and cooks marshmallows to perfection. Although slightly smaller than the one I had during my childhood, it's more user-friendly and easy to clean than the older model."
Quick tip10. Best Easy-To-Use : Sharper Image Electric S’mores Maker
The Sharper Image Electric S’mores Maker with an electric heater and stainless steel housing is an efficient marshmallow roaster and makes perfectly roasted marshmallows for delicious s’mores. In addition to the heater, the product also comprises four stainless steel roasting forks/ s’mores sticks, a top cover, and a four-compartment tray design for the ingredients. With its unique features and superior quality, the Sharper Image Electric S’mores Maker may come in handy during birthday parties, holidays, and special celebrations. Plug the power cord into an AC outlet to use the maker.
Pros
- No open flame
- Safe and easy to use
- Comes with a knob to adjust the temperature
- Light display to know if power is on or off
Cons
- Generating heat to melt the marshmallow can be a bit challenging
"This device accurately softened marshmallows for s'mores and added warmth to the room as well. It's very well-crafted and has been an excellent addition, which makes our family game nights more fun. All thanks to this device, I can keep the little s'mores lovers happy all year round!"
11. Best User-Friendly : PrepSolutions Progressive International GMMC-680 S’mores Maker Microwave
This portable s’mores maker is user-friendly and works on a microwave. The product comes with a water reservoir and a tray with two sidearms. Making s’mores with this product is simple. You just need to fill in the water reservoir, place the marshmallow and chocolate layer sandwiched between two graham crackers on the tray and microwave it for 30 seconds or less. The sidearms ensure the marshmallows neither over-expand nor overcook.
Pros
- Measures about 7.5″x 6.5″x 4″
- Easy to clean
- Dishwasher-safe
- Safe and BPA-free
Cons
- Reservoir may need to be refilled after every use
- Not suitable for making multiple S’mores
12. Best Easy-To-Clean: Coleman S’more Maker
Image: Coleman The Coleman S’more Maker comes with a chrome-plated steel base and cooking basket and. To prepare tasty s’mores, place the ingredients on the steel base, lock them down in the cooking basket, and hold the arrangement over the fire with the safety handle. In a few minutes, your delicious treats of s’mores are ready to be served.
Pros
- Measures 26″ x 5.2″ x 0.6″
- User-friendly and easy to clean
- Works on the grill as well
- Handle is long enough and does not transfer heat
Cons
- Graham cracker may slide
- May get a bit messy cooking on it
"I never quite grasped the s'mores craze until I tried this Coleman toaster S'more maker. It turns out a warm and gooey treat is more satisfying than cold graham crackers and hard chocolate. This quality piece has traveled with me on many fun camping trips and continues to serve me well."
How To Choose The Right S’mores Makers?
Here are a few tips for choosing the right s’mores makers available online.
- Source of heat: Some of the s’more makers need an open flame to function, while many others work on electricity (no-open-flame s’mores maker). If kids are likely to use the s’mores maker, opt for one with “no open flame.”
- Size: With some s’more makers, you can make two s’mores at a time, while with a few others, the number can go up to six at a time. The latter may be an ideal choice for family movie nights and for those who love to host parties at home or have a big family.
- Also check if the s’mores maker is
- User friendly
- Dishwasher friendly
- Comes with a roasting screen for flame protection (safe for kids)
- Can be used indoors, outdoors, or both
- Pricing and warranty
Sarah Blair says, “The goal of any home chef should be to purchase equipment that is used often. Frequency of use and safety are important factors you should consider when choosing cooking equipment. Select a model that best suits your entire family’s needs and cooking style.”
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can I carry s’mores makers while traveling?
Yes, you can travel with compact s’mores makers that do not run on electricity. For example, s’mores makers that run on canned chafing or heat fuel are an ideal option for traveling.
2. Which s’mores makers give the most authentic results?
Every s’mores maker has its own benefits. However, s’mores makers that use open flame technology give the most authentic results, whereas s’mores makers with no open flame are a much safer option for kids.
3. Is there a healthy way to make s’mores?
S’mores are basically marshmallows, which do not have much nutritional value. You can make them healthy by eating them with crackers that are high in fiber and dark chocolate that contains antioxidants.
Why Trust MomJunction?
Wedetso Chirhah is a writer and reviewer who specializes in kitchen and household categories and seeks to inform his readers about the best products. He curates lists after conducting holistic research on various products and adheres to the review guidelines, so readers are guided towards products best suited to their needs. In this article on the best s’mores makers, he has reviewed each product thoroughly before presenting to you his list. You will also find a buying guide, which can help you make the right choice.
The Bottom Line
The best s’mores makers can help you prepare these delectable snacks in no time whenever you crave them. When choosing the right one, consider the heating element–it could be electric, oven or microwave, or grill. Also, ensure it is made of high quality materials and is easy to clean and maintain. Further, if you plan on making s’mores with your children, consider whether the s’mores makers are child-friendly. Our top picks on this list are the easy-to-clean Nostalgia Electric Stainless Steel S’mores Maker with a flameless electric heater, the easy-to-use Progressive Prep Solutions PS-68BR microwave s’mores maker that makes two s’mores in 30 seconds, and the portable Cuisinart S’more to Love STL-611 Six-S’more Maker that can be used over an oven or a grill.
Recommended Articles:
