Image: MomJunction Design Team
If your toilet keeps leaking or you hear a monotonous hissing sound, it may be time to replace the toilet flapper. Toilet flappers are an integral part of the toilet because they can flush and drain water from the tank into the toilet bowl. The flapper is attached to the tank lever by a small chain. However, the flapper will degrade over time and cause noise and leaks. This leads to water wastage.
With the correct type of flapper, you can overcome these problems immediately. Choose the best toilet flapper from our list and test them out.
Top Picks
Types Of Flappers
There are three types of toilet flappers that provide different functions.
1. Rubber flapper
The flapper made of rubber resembles the shape of an upside-down hat. It is usually installed on the valve’s opening and used in toilets. There is a small hole at the bottom of the model that allows water to flow. The water, when flushed, enters the hat and increases the weight. When the reservoir tank reaches full storage capacity, the flapper eventually lowers, thereby closing the valve. The rubber flappers last long and are adjustable.
2. Seat disk flapper
This is the oldest type of flapper for older toilet models and has the oldest kind of disk that fits and snaps above the valve. The flapper’s lever system can lift the disk during flushing and then lower it again to fill the water tank. It is made of a strong piece of rubber and easy to replace. However, several parts attached to the level system may make the device bulky.
3. Tank ball flapper
This type of flapper design can fit specific toilets, so it is not common. The tank ball flapper has a large ball with various shapes. It does not require any chain system because it can be attached to the lever arm by metallic rods screwed into the tank’s top.
10 Best Toilet Flappers
1. Best Durable: Korky Toto Toilet Flapper
Image: Korky 
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
The 3,164 positive customer reviews on Amazon attest to the product’s quality.
Korky Toto is designed with an extra-large surface, and it fits most toilet models. The time-tested, durable flapper is made of high-quality chlorazone rubber, which can withstand bacteria, chlorine, hard water, and well water, making it last longer than standard flappers. The model also includes a three-inch flapper and stainless chain. The high-quality product is universal and suitable for older and modern toilet models. It lasts long, and the toilet flapper assembly is quite easy. Watch this video to get a detailed review of the product.
2. Best Chlorine-Resistant: Fluidmaster Toilet Flapper
Image: Fluidmaster 
Point To ConsiderWhy We Think It's Worth Buying
This product is a hit with users, evidenced by the 2,060 fine reviews on Amazon.
Fluidmaster’s universal toilet flappers have efficient built-in micro ban protection, keeping the flapper clean by resisting flapper breakdown caused by bacteria. Its universal design fits most toilets, including U.S. standard units with 3.5 gallons per flush toilets or larger. It can fit perfectly on flush valves with or without mounting ears. The robust flapper is chlorine-resistant, which ensures its durability. Here’s a video to help you know more about this product.
3. Best Rust-Resistant: Essential Value Toilet Flapper
Did You Know?With high-quality rubber material, the tried-and-tested Essential Value toilet flapper provides a tight, rubber seal. It comes with a chain made up of stainless steel with a clip hook. The flapper is durable and not easy to rust or break. The toilet flapper replacement has been carefully polished and has a smooth surface without burrs. The three-inch toilet tank flapper easily adjusts to fit flush valves, and the durable and flexible rubber helps form a stronger seal. This toilet flapper helps save water and is resistant to chlorine and bacteria.
Korky Toto Toilet Flapper Best Durable | Fluidmaster Toilet Flapper Best Chlorine-Resistant | Essential Value Toilet Flapper Best Rust-Resistant | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weight | 0.14 Pounds | 0.32 ounces | 2.11 ounces |
| Number of Items | 1 | - | - |
| Dimensions | 5"L x 4"W | 1.93 x 4.25 x 7.5 inches | - |
| Color | Red | Red | Red |
| Material | Synthetic Rubber | Plastic | Rubber |
| Rating | |||
| Reviews | 3,164 | 2,060 | 2,355 |
| Price | $10.6 | $4.48 | $10.99 |
4. Best Universal Fit: Korky 100BP Ultra High-Performance Flapper
Image: Korky The Korky two-inch flapper is designed to have universal compatibility and can be adjusted to fit almost every tank size. It has multiple adjustable settings to ensure a perfect fit for most two-inch toilets from popular brands, including TOTO, Mansfield, Kohler, and American Standard. Made of high-quality material, the trusted and tested flapper is easy to install and can replace float-style, rigid, and rubber-frame flappers. By quickly fixing leaking and running toilets, it helps save water.
5. Best Water-Saving: Lydia’s Deal Universal Toilet Flapper
This three-inch flapper by Lydia’s Deal is made of long-lasting rubber that helps create a strong seal when installed. It reduces the chances of ghost flushing, twisting, and running toilets, making it an ideal flapper for water-saving toilets. The tried-and-tested flapper is corrosion-resistant and highly durable. Its solid frame offers stability and is lightweight at only two ounces. It is universally compatible with a majority of toilets and can help keep a check on water leaking.
Pros
- Helps save 3.5 gallons of water per flush
- Easy to install without tools
- Can be used to replace corroded flappers
- Can fit most three-inch flush valve toilets
Cons
- Chain may get tangled easily
- Flapper may not close sometimes
"Recently, I installed these toilet flaps that fit well in my toilet. It is quite durable and tight and prevents leaks. I used to have ghost-flushing issues, but they are now resolved. I find it very practical and looks like it will last long."
6. Best Easy-To-Install: Qualihome Toilet Flapper
Qualihome is an easy-to-install flapper model that does not require any tools to work effectively and resists chemicals in water systems, including chlorine. This high-quality toilet flapper is made of TPR material for durability and is easy to install. It also includes a stainless steel chain and a hook, making it easy to replace.
7. Best With Silicone Seals: American Standard Vormax Flapper
Image: American Standard Looking for a solid toilet flapper to test out? The American Standard Vormax toilet flapper is suitable for Vormax toilets that feature flushing technology. It is built to be durable and features a secure metal toilet chain that provides long-lasting use. The flapper fixes issues with ghost flushing and leaking or sticking valves. It is easy to assemble and install and includes silicone seals, a teeter bar, and an installation guide for convenience.
8. Best Water Saving: Hibbent Store Toilet Flapper
Image: Hibbent Hibbent Store’s three-inch toilet flapper can be a good substitute for the standard American flapper. This two-piece toilet flappers set can perfectly replace old, inefficient, leaky toilet flappers to reduce water waste. The flapper is easy to install and does not require any installation tools. It includes a stainless chain with a clip hook.
9. Best Chlorine-Resistant: Mansfield Plumbing Univ Flapper
Image: Mansfield The Mansfield Plumbing Flapper is specifically designed for Mansfield toilets and measures three inches in size. Made of chlorine-resistant rubber, it ensures a long service life and eliminates the need for frequent replacements at short intervals. This universal flapper also has two different-sized arm holes, making it compatible with various toilets, and it is easy to install and assemble.
10. Best Compatible: Uming Toilet Flapper
Image: Uming Why We Think It's Worth Buying
Do not miss out on this product that has earned 678 positive reviews on Amazon.
Uming’s durable rubber toilet baffle can repair leaky toilet flappers, running toilets, double flush, and worn toilet flappers. It does not require any tools to install and stays for a long time. The universal toilet flapper is compatible with Kohler, Gerber, Toto’s two-inch flush valve toilets, and most American standard toilet tanks. It is made of durable soft rubber and a corrosion-resistant stainless steel chain, making it an ideal replacement for old and rusty flappers.
How To Choose The Right Toilet Flapper?
Before buying the best toilet flapper, consider the following factors.
- Size: Finding the right flapper size is crucial. The size of the valve will determine the flapper you need. If the flapper is too small or too large, the seal may loosen, and the leaking problem may persist. Some flappers can fit the two-inch valves, while some can comfortably fit the two-inch valves.
- Quality: Choose high-quality products made of chemical-resistant and water-resistant materials. The best flappers prevent mildew. Rubber, silicon, or plastic products are trustworthy and durable.
- Age of your toilet: Before buying a toilet baffle, check the age of the toilet since many old toilets may use old-fashioned toilet flappers, or new flappers may not fit them. Review and research your needs, then buy the best flapper accordingly.
- Type: There are adjustable and non-adjustable toilet flappers. You need to know the amount of water the flapper can flush to understand its type. Non-adjustable flappers are limited to two-inch valves.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. How often should I replace a toilet flapper?
There are no set intervals at which you need to replace the toilet’s flapper. A toilet flapper can work for two to five years and should be changed when it starts to malfunction.
2. How do I stop a toilet flapper from leaking?
You can try removing any mineral build-up caused due to hard water or changing the tube or chain of the installed flapper to stop the flapper from leaking.
3. How do I know if my toilet flapper is bad?
Your toilet’s flapper has probably gone bad if your toilet is constantly leaking water, making a buzzing sound, or not flushing at full capacity.
Why Trust MomJunction?
We have compiled this list of the best toilet flappers in the market after going through different websites and user reviews to understand the users’ requirements. Keeping your convenience and quality parameters in mind, detailed specifications of each product have been provided. Moreover, you will also find a section on the different types of flappers available and a buying guide to help you choose the right one.
The Bottom Line
Now that you know what toilet flappers are and how they function, it’s time to pick the best toilet flapper for your needs. They are of various types, and each comes with its own set of features and benefits. Before choosing one, consider factors such as the size, quality, and age of your toilet to make sure you land the right flapper. Our top pick is the Korky 100BP Ultra High-Performance Flapper, known for its easy installation and highly universal design. Another viable choice is the chlorine-resistant and durable Fluidmaster Toilet Flapper. If your flushing mechanism isn’t working smoothly, replacing the toilet flapper might be the ideal solution.
Infographic: How To Replace Toilet Flappers?
The toilet flapper is a toilet tank component that regulates the water flow. Over time, it can wear out or become damaged, leading to leaks and water wastage. It is crucial to replace the flapper soon in such cases. Check out the following infographic to learn how to replace your toilet flapper without breaking a sweat.
Illustration: Momjunction Design Team
Recommended Articles:
