15 Best Return Gifts Ideas For 1st Birthday Party in 2024

If you are celebrating your kid’s first birthday soon and looking for return gift ideas, you have come to the right place. We have compiled a list of the best return gift ideas for a 1st birthday party to share with you. These gifts are unique, memorable, and appeal to children and parents. They are durable, long-lasting, practical, and attractive to please your guests. So, check out our list to explore thoughtful return gifts for the first birthday.

In This Article

15 Best Return Gifts For Your Baby’s 1st Birthday Party

1. Best To Enhance Creativity: Play-Doh Party Bag Dough


Why We Think It's Worth Buying

Over 15,918 customers on Amazon have opined that this is one of the best products in its category.

Playing with clay is fun. Kids can create anything they want and make multiple storylines out of this dough. It promotes imagination and creativity in kids, making it one of the best first-birthday return gifts. This tried-and-tested playdough set gift is suitable for kids aged two years and above.

Item Weight: 9.6 ounces | Product Dimensions: 2.01 x 7.87 x 10 inches.


  • Contains 15 cans of modeling compound
  • Made of child-safe material
  • Each packet comes with a gift tag
  • Soft and smooth clay
  • Travel-friendly containers


  • May feel sticky
  • May have a slightly strong smell

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

About 15,918 reviewers on Amazon have given their seal of approval to the product.

2. Best Unique Party Favors: DG Sports Party Gift Favors for Kids

Looking for a funky return gift? Have a look at this set of various accessories that kids would love to own. This set contains 12 pairs of sunglasses, 12 emoji wristbands, and 12 whistles. It is suitable for kids aged five years and above.

Item Weight: 1.32 pounds


  • Sunglasses have smoked lens
  • Long-lasting silicone bracelets
  • Whistles can also be used as keychains
  • Includes fun pouch for convenient gifting


  • Some pieces may not be durable enough

Our Reviewer's Experience

"My students were thrilled to receive these goodies during this Holiday season. The individually packed bags made it easy to distribute them. Although additional variety would have been appreciated, the overall response from kids has been positive."

3. Best Toy Collection: Kissdream Carnival Prizes for Kids

When you have children of all ages attending your baby’s party, selecting one single return gift can become difficult. So, why not give a bouquet of small items like this set of toys that all children can enjoy. This birthday return gift set is suitable for children aged three years and above.

Material: Plastic | Color: 130 Pcs | Item Weight: 2.09 pounds


  • Contains a total of 152 toy pieces
  • Includes 20 different kinds of gift items
  • Allows for customization
  • Meets the American toy safety standards
  • Made of safe materials
  • Sturdy objects


  • Some pieces may be small in size
  • Some pieces may not be durable enough

Our Reviewer's Experience

"This assortment of toys was a hit as party favors during my son’s birthday. While all the toys were entertaining, the dinosaurs were a crowd favorite owing to their realistic-looking paint job. Plus, the robust construction has helped them survive multiple falls and throws."

protip_icon Quick tip
Pack these carnival toy pieces in small pouches, add a thank-you sticker or tag to them, and then arrange them in a basket to make them appear more classy.

4. Best Assortment Of Prizes: Amy & Benton 120PCS Carnival Prizes

This huge goodie bag containing 120 pieces of gift items makes an ideal party favor for those who are looking to gift their guests something different. This unique birthday party return gift set is suitable for kids aged three years and above.

Item Weight: 1.65 pounds | Product Dimensions: 10.24 x 7.48 x 2.36 inches.


  • Includes a variety of items such as cars, water guns, balls, and rings
  • Well-packed gift box to prevent damage in transit
  • Made of safe, non-toxic material
  • ASTM Certified


  • Some pieces may be tiny
  • Material quality may not be up to the mark

Our Reviewer's Experience

"This assortment of toys was a hit across different ages during my kid's birthday party. Although some pieces were smaller than expected, the diversity of colors and toys made the party even more vibrant for everyone involved."

5. Best Truck Toy Collection: Funcorn Toys Mini Truck Toy Kit Set

When you have a lot of little children who love playing with tiny vehicles on your guest list, get them this pull-back truck toy set as a return gift. The 12-piece birthday return gift set contains all kinds of construction trucks and is suitable for children aged three years and above.

Item Weight: 7.4 ounces


  • Lightweight and sturdy build to withstand frequent collisions
  • Most suited for pretend play
  • Encourages children to use their imagination
  • Sturdy and durable


  • Small vehicle pieces
  • May have a strong plastic smell

Our Reviewer's Experience

"Both adults and kids found joy in these cars’ vibrant colors and moving parts when I pulled them out during a recent family gathering. They did seem smaller than expected, but that also made them easy to carry around. All in all, they have quickly become well-loved companions regardless of age."

6. Best For Ages Three And Above: Chimager Mini Bubble Wands Assortment Party Favors

Soap bubbles may create a lot of mess, but they are super-fun. These mini bubble wands come in colorful tubes filled with soapy water to create big bubbles. Loved by reviewers, these toys are suitable for children aged three years and above.

Item Weight: 11.7 ounces


  • Non-toxic, odorless soap solution
  • Safe for children to use
  • Available in various colors
  • Durable and easy to use


  • May leak if not closed properly
  • Pieces may be smaller than you expect

Our Reviewer's Experience

"These bubble wands are very durable, and the no-mess design has allowed my kids to play with them indoors too. However, a larger soap capacity would have been nice. Nonetheless, they are both charming and functional."

protip_icon Quick tip
If you accidentally spill the soapy water, you can easily make it by mixing two cups of dish soap, two tablespoons of cornstarch, and four tablespoons of glycerin in a half gallon of water.

7. Best Budget Party Favors: IP I Premium 120 Pcs Toy Assortment

Containing 12 different types of toys and balloons, this 120-piece gift set makes one gigantic party gift. These fun gifts for kids are inexpensive and of high quality.

Material: Plastic | Item Weight: 1.21 pounds | Product Dimensions: 10.55 x 6.93 x 2.68 inches.


  • Contains water guns, stampers, whistles, chuzzle balls, and more
  • All items are certified child-safe
  • Made of sturdy material


  • Small items
  • Some pieces may not be as durable as the others

My Personal Experience

"This party toy mix has been jackpot filling for goody bags and piñatas. While there were a few quality hiccups, the variety was a clear winner, bringing many smiles and delight. Hence, I plan on using them for the next party too."

8. Best Engaging Toy: Neliblu Airplane Gliders for Kids

Airplanes never fail to fascinate young minds. Children love to play with mini planes, miniature cars or vehicles. So, why not gift them colorful planes of their own? These airplane gliders feature smooth rounded edges and are suitable for children aged three years and above.

Material: Paper | Color: Multicolor | Item Weight: 6.4 ounces


  • Contains 72 colorful airplanes
  • Made of foam material
  • Safe gifts for kids
  • Lightweight design
  • Available in a variety of designs and colors
  • Easy assembly


  • May be slightly fragile
  • Nose weight might be slightly heavy

Our Reviewer's Experience

"My little aviation lover was thrilled to see his room decorated with these airplanes on his birthday. Their assembly was a breeze, and while their flight can be unpredictable, they have been a hit with my son and his friends."


Why We Think It's Worth Buying

Do not miss out on this product that has earned 2,686 positive reviews on Amazon.

9. Best For Fun: Mikulala Birthday Party Favors for Kids

Looking for an interesting gift? How about these glow-in-the-dark rings? This package comes with 36 different light-up rings that are the ideal birthday party return gifts for kids aged three years and above. This simple review video will help you figure out more gift ideas for your event.

Batteries: 1 Unknown batteries required | Item Weight: 11.3 ounces | Product Dimensions: 3.94 x 3.94 x 3.94 inches.


  • Made of thermoplastic rubber
  • Flexible rings
  • One-size-fits-all
  • Button-activated attractive blinking lights
  • Available in nine assorted colors and animal shapes


  • Batteries may not last long
  • Pieces may be slightly flimsy
protip_icon Quick tip
Fill these glow-in-the-dark rings in a transparent jar and then place the jar in a dark corner to make them appear more fascinating to your guests.

10. Best For Reducing Stress: Scione Pack Light Up Bracelets

Scione Pack Light Up Bracelets Image: Scionespinner

Regular bracelets seem too boring when children have the option of flaunting these cool glowing bracelets. This fun gift set contains 24 light-up bracelets that are suitable for children aged three years and above.

Color: 24 Pack Kids Party Play Bracelets | Batteries: 12 LR44 batteries required | Item Weight: 1.3 pounds | Product Dimensions: 7.87 x 1.96 x 0.78 inches.


  • Each friendship bracelet holds a spinner to relieve stress and anxiety
  • Spinner flashes colored lights in three modes
  • Double buckle design for a secure fit
  • Long-lasting battery


  • Batteries may come off easily
  • Pieces may not be durable enough

Our Reviewer's Experience

"I am pretty impressed with how well these spin watches fit different-sized wrists. Their vibrant colors and unique design had everyone hooked during my daughter's birthday party. I recommend them for the playful entertainment that they bring."


Why We Think It's Worth Buying

More than 4,992 buyers on Amazon have said the product lives up to the hype.

11. Best For Customization: Adorox Jungle Safari Zoo Animal Cardboard Favor Treat Boxes

These cute cardboard boxes are ideal for packing customized gifts. When you have a few guests, you can give them the same gift boxes but pack different stuff inside so each one gets something special from your side.

Color: Safari | Item Weight: 11 ounces | Product Dimensions: 9.8 x 9.5 x 0.5 inches


  • Jungle-themed empty cardboard boxes
  • Durable and sturdy
  • Easy to assemble
  • Encourages imaginative play


  • Flimsy bottom
  • Could have been a few inches bigger

Our Reviewer's Experience

"These animal-themed party favor boxes enhanced the charm of my little one’s birthday party. The variety of animal designs ensures that the kids get to pick their favorite. Plus, their assembly was easy, and even though petite, the bags could comfortably hold a mix of goodies."

12. Best For Motor Skills:  Neliblu Fun Puzzle Balls

When you have children attending your child’s party, you can arrange for some extra-special gifts for them. This packet of 12 items includes puzzle toys suitable for older children and makes an excellent birthday party return gift.

Item Weight: 9.6 ounces | Product Dimensions: 8.82 x 6.69 x 2.91 inches.


  • Contains balls that help reduce stress and anxiety
  • Strengthens focus and attention
  • Enhances motor skill development
  • Portable and attractive


  • May not be easy to assemble
  • May not be the best gifts for younger children

Our Reviewer's Experience

"These puzzle balls provided a mix of mental gymnastics and fun during this holiday season. Their color and design variation have only enhanced their charm. Although setting them back requires patience, they have been an excellent option to keep the little ones and adults occupied."


Why We Think It's Worth Buying

The product has garnered more than 3,181 positive reviews on Amazon.

13. Best For Learnng Rhythm: Neliblu Bulk Classroom Party Pack 12 Cymbals with Handles

Artcreativity Neon Tambourines Image: Artcreativity

Kids love to make noise. Gifting them these cymbals could help bring some rhythm to the noise. These colorful musical instrument come with plastic handles for convenient usage and are suitable for kids aged three years and above.

Item Weight: 1.19 pounds


  • Ideal for entertaining young kids
  • Helps develop a sense of rhythm in kids
  • Available in various bright colors
  • High quality plastic and metal
  • Comfortably sized for small hands to hold


  • May be a bit noisy

14. Best For Ages Six And Above:  Mini Animals Building Blocks Sets

How about gifting your guests a building set? Each block set comes with an instructions manual to help children build their respective animals.

Item Weight: 9.6 ounces | Product Dimensions: 8.9 x 6.69 x 2.28 inches.


  • Includes 12 animal building block toys
  • Each toy is independently packed
  • Comes in different shapes and colors
  • Helps improve imagination


  • Not suitable for younger children
  • Instructions may not be easy to follow

Our Reviewer's Experience

"The block sets have come in handy in keeping the younger brood away from the screens this holiday season. Its assembly instructions were a bit cryptic, but the results and joy they brought were worth the tiny trouble."

15. Best ForAdventure Lovers: Kicko 12 Toy Binoculars with Neck String

If your party guests are older kids, this pair of binoculars might excite them. This quality-tested set comes with 12 pairs of binoculars.

Item Weight: 1.21 pounds | Product Dimensions: 12.09 x 9.09 x 3.58 inches.


  • Made of durable, non-toxic plastic
  • Available in three vibrant colors
  • Encourages children to explore their surroundings
  • Ideal gifts for adventurous children


  • Strap may not be durable
  • Magnification could have been slightly higher
Our Reviewer's Experience

"I handed out these binoculars to the little ones during our family hiking trip, and they instantly started using them to spot squirrels and ants. They even survived a few falls, and the size is perfect for little hands."

*The prices provided in this article are based on the latest available information. However, they may vary due to changes in pricing by the seller and/or promotional offers.

Simple Tips For Selecting The Best Return Gifts For A Baby’s First Birthday Party

  • Not all of the kids on your guest list would be of the same age. Thus, it is best to select return gifts based on the average age group of the children invited for the party.
  • If you have a themed-party planned, then opt for gifts that go with the party theme.
  • If you want your guests to receive the same gifts but still be unique, you can buy the same item in several colors.
  • Do not give toys that can become choking hazards for your young guests. Any gift that is likely to cause allergy or injury is also best avoided.
  • Lastly, buy gifts that suit your budget.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is a unique way to celebrate the first birthday?

Celebrating the first birthday brings great joy to any parent, as this marks an important milestone or event. It’s all about creating the best memories for many more years to come. You can celebrate it simply and uniquely by going on a special vacation to a place that is special to you. Or you can choose to keep the celebration brief with limited guests cause long celebrations and hectic schedules might overwhelm your toddler. Plan for a pre-birthday photoshoot to create lasting memories, and create your own birthday theme that reflects your special bond with the baby.

2. Is returning a gift rude?

Yes, returning a gift is surely not acceptable manners. Instead, you can find more polite ways to let the guest know by politely asking them if you can exchange it for something better or just by saying thank you for the time and passing it to someone else or gift it to someone whom you think would love the gift.

3. What is the best return gift for a birthday party?

Here, in this article, we have listed some of the best return gifts suitable for the first birthday party.

Why Trust MomJunction?

Selecting appealing yet useful return gifts can be challenging. Thus, Priti Bose has come up with a list of the best return gift ideas for your baby’s 1st birthday party. She has carefully explored and compared various options available before compiling this list. The suggested items cater to the taste and liking of children of different age groups. Moreover, she has also included a buying guide to help you choose some awesome return gifts for your guests.

The Bottom Line

Your child’s 1st birthday is always a special one. Hence, choosing a sensible and useful return gift is important as it is part of the celebration that the guests take back with them. This list of the best return gift ideas for a 1st birthday party includes fun playthings from bubble dispensers to non-toxic clay like the Play-Doh Party Bag Dough. While choosing the gifts, ensure they are age-appropriate for young children and do not contain toxic components. For instance, you could get the versatile Kissdream Carnival Prizes For Kids if you plan on throwing a large party or buy the Neliblu Airplane Gliders to facilitate imaginative play. Further, consider buying gifts that are useful as well as fun.

Infographic: Safety Considerations For Buying Return Gifts For One-Year-Olds

A return gift is like a tangible thank you given to the guests who have come to celebrate your baby’s first birthday. The return gift can also act as memorabilia of the baby’s yesteryears. Check out the infographic for gifting ideas for one-year-olds.

How To Buy Return Gifts That Are Safe For One Year Olds(infographic)

Illustration: Momjunction Design Team

Recommended Articles

Was this article helpful?
Like buttonDislike button
The following two tabs change content below.
Ramona Dejesus-Curtis is a wife, mother of a preteen on the autism spectrum, whom she also homeschools, autism advocate, and entrepreneur. She has a YouTube channel called K.i.D Clothes TV where she educates parents and caregivers on children's health, fashion, and development. Ramona also has an online children clothing line called K.i.D Clothes where she helps parents choose the right...read full bio